Archive for the ‘Uncategorized’ Category


AVIATION FUEL PROBLEMS AND SOLUTIONS: FROM RIFINERY TO WINGTIP



Just Published!

I’m delighted to announce the publication of the book that I co-edited with Drs. Moshe Rabaev, Joanna Bauldreay, Raj Shah, and Mr. Liel Mazar. The book can be purchased at: https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-032-05514-9. Or via this QR code:



Contents

Aviation Fuel Problems and Solutions: From Refinery to Wingtip has 15 chapters, each written by one or more internationally recognized subject matter experts. Here’s the table of contents:

1 An Introduction to Aviation Fuels and Specifications 1
Joanna M. Bauldreay
Abstract Flight safety has been the primary driver for the development of avia-tion fuels and their governin specifications since first piston-engined aircraft and later turbine engine-aircraft were developed. For over 70 years in the case of turbine fuels, problems and issues with fuel storage, distribution and usage have led to the specifications being modified as much as the aircraft and engines have changed. Producing fuels to match current specifications reduces the risk of fuel-related prob-lems not associated with handling challenges. This chapter provides an overview of fuel and specification changes, particularly in relation to civil jet fuels, and explains the main performance requirements embodied in the fuel specifications. These are living documents and nowadays allow for the use of synthetic fuel components; additional feedstocks and specification changes to accommodate them can be expected in response to environmental pressures.

2 Manufacture of Jet Fuel in Refineries 29
Amiram Groweiss and Joanna M. Bauldreay
Abstract Aviation fuels are produced in oil refineries around the world mainly by atmospheric-pressure distillation of crude oil. Refinery activities that take account of crude properties and quality requirements for their complete range of products are essential to produce problem-free, fit-for-purpose aviation fuels. This chapter focusses on jet fuel production, from distillation and heavy stream upgrading processes that set most bulk properties, to finishing processes that control cleanliness and stability. It also addresses briefly more activities in the refineries, such as additivation, sampling, testing, and product release. The slightl different requirements for military grade fuels are discussed as are trends in refinery operations toward production of future fuels.

3 Building Safety and Performance into Synthetic Aviation Turbine Fuels 77
Mark Rumizen
Abstract Concerns about the security of the supply of aviation fuels, and more recently the sustainability of aviation fuels, have challenged the aviation industry to expand the allowable components used in jet fuel manufacture. This has led to the ASTM D4054 guidance material that sets out how to confirm the suitability of candidate synthetic components. The ASTM D7566 specification then defines requirements for new components and blends made with conventional jet fuel compo-nents that can then drop into jet fuel distribution systems as Jet A or Jet A-1 meeting ASTM D1655, Def Stan 91-091, or similar existing specifications. The evolution of these changes is described, as well as more recent changes that are now allowing some synthetic materials to be coprocessed with conventional refinery streams to create jet fuels with sustainable content. Industry jet fuel product quality guides, such as EI 1533, provide guidance for manufacturers and suppliers of semisynthetic jet fuels that supplement the specification controls used to ensure fit-for-purpose jet fuels.

4 Aviation Gasoline and Other Fuels for Piston Engine Aircraft 91
Alisdair Clark, Roger Gaughan, and Melanie Kimble-Thom
Abstract Aviation gasoline represents the first fuel specifically developed for flight in an era when the spark ignition piston engine ruled the sky. While the industry largely transitioned to the aviation turbine engine many years ago, the piston engine fleet still performs a useful and important role in global transport. Light aircraft represent a unique solution where ground transport is challenged due to adverse terrain, for example by desert, jungle, water, mountains and snow. In addition, the fleet offers pilot training and recreation to promote aviation across the world, foundations on which the wider industry is built. Aviation gasoline is the primary fuel for these aircraft and, in this chapter, the background to the fuel is presented together with its unique attributes, challenges and solutions. Further, details for aviation compression ignition (diesel) piston engines are also included to promote understanding of alternative power sources.

5 Additives in Aviation Fuels 141
Dietmar Posselt, Joanna M. Bauldreay, Amiram Groweiss, and Patrick Bosmans
Abstract Aviation fuel specifications set out minimum requirements for a given liquid to be accepted as fit for purpose for use in aircraft. These requirements are a combination of compositional restraints, physical properties and performance criteria that, historically, have proven to produce a fuel that is acceptable for Aviation. Additives have been incorporated into the fuel specifications to help address inherent functional and performance limitations with the fuel. Aviation fuel additives, whether deliberately added or present because of crossover from other fuels during storage and transportation, are tightly controlled in jet fuel specifications. The chapter describes additive usage as well as the approval processes involved for aviation additives to be accepted into aviation fuels, focussing on jet fuel applications. Challenges with additive usage are also addressed and ways to understand, prevent or mitigate the issues are discussed.

6 The Effects of the Fuel Composition on Non-metal Materials in Aircraft Systems 187
Melanie Kimble-Thom and Alan Fletcher
Abstract The effect of the composition of an aviation fuel, be it kerosene or gasoline, on the non-metallic components of the aircraft fuel system cannot be underestimated. Examples of unintended or undesirable effects of fuel compositional changes include leaking of fuel-wetted seals, swelling of polymeric fuel hoses, and removal of organic coatings from metal substrates. These events illuminate the importance of considering the impacts of changes in fuel formulation or composition. The complexity of the potential list of non-metallic materials, and determining the means of testing and evaluating data, is not immediately obvious. Considering the increasing contemporary efforts to develop alternative fuel sources, formulations, and compositions, the activities to support those challenges become more expansive, touching materials which may have a legacy of decades without being reviewed. While not an exhaustive discussion, the following chapter endeavors to provide a foundation for identifying challenges and developing the means for evaluating data.

7 Aviation Fuel Stability 223
Steven Zabarnick, Robert E. Morris, and Josefa Ben-Asher
Abstract The term “jet fuel stability” covers a variety of fuel properties that result from the fuel’s chemical composition upon production, as well as changes to these properties upon fuel degradation in the supply chain and upon use in aircraft engines. Stability is ordinarily separated into storage stability, the ability of a fuel to resist degradation during supply chain transport and storage, and thermal stability, the ability of the fuel to resist degradation during exposure to relatively high tempera-tures. This chapter summarizes the fuel degradation processes which occur in these two regimes, details the test methods employed, and offers guidance in preventing and mitigating the effects of these degradation mechanisms.

8 Supply Chain Risk Management (SCRM) of Fuel for Aviation 249
Richard Bruce Knapp, Barbara Mooney, Curtis T. Stough, James M. Eberhardt, Renrick Atkins, Rebecca Purcell, Lori Taylor, Kelley Jackson-Cherry, Cheng Yen, Yan Guo, Makeena Stephens, Daniel Baniszewski, Keith Mills, Mark Mizrahi, Michael Heidbreder, and Patricia Wilkins
Abstract Supply Chain Risk Management (SCRM) within the petroleum industry often represents a complex logistical challenge. Risks include aspects such as planning, identification, analysis, response planning, and monitoring. The petroleum supply chain involves diverse processes, from sourcing to delivery, with a focus on collaboration due to its segmented nature. Risk factors can be found at different supply chain segments, including source of supply, refinery, distribution, and storage.

9 Common Practice in Aviation Fuel Handling Equipment 269
Pierre Poitras, Jim Gammon, Daniel E. Kadlecek, and Amy Carico
Abstract Ensuring flight safety starts with proper handling of aviation fuel. This chapter explores key practices for maintaining equipment, managing fueling operations, and avoiding mistakes like misfueling and contamination. It highlights the importance of delivering the correct grade and quantity of fuel, with a focus on over-wing fueling challenges. Practical measures such as using grade-selective nozzles, clear wing decals, and verification steps are discussed to reduce the risk of errors. The chapter also addresses the increasing problem of additive misfueling, particularly confusion between Diesel Exhaust Fluid (DEF) and Fuel System Icing Inhibitor (FSII). It explains the consequences of such mistakes and emphasizes the importance of regular testing and calibration to detect issues before they escalate. Maintenance and storage of fueling equipment are equally critical. From using dust caps to prevent contamination to identifying wear and tear early, the role of fuelers in maintaining fuel quality is emphasized. Proper storage of sampling buckets and attention to hydrant systems are also covered as essential parts of the process. The chapter compares fueling operations at large airports, where equipment is maintained rigorously, to remote locations, where longer storage times and periodic maintenance increase risks. Regardless of the setting, the chapter underscores the need for proactive main-tenance and strict adherence to industry standards to ensure the reliability of fuel handling systems and, ultimately, flight safety.

10 Aviation Fuel Filtration Systems 295
John Leonard, Kimberly Morrison, and Samantha Glenn
Abstract This chapter provides an overview of aviation fuel filtration systems. Filtration systems are designed primarily to remove particulate contamination from fuel products as they are transported from refinery fuel tanks, ultimately to aircraft. Filtration systems also strip dispersed and free water from fuels. EI maintains EI 1550, handbook on equipment used for the maintenance and delivery of clean aviation fuel. The handbook includes all published and approved technology and provides additional details that are not covered in this chapter. This chapter will describe different types of filtration equipment, filter media, and the most common problems that can degrade filter performance.

11 Insights into Aviation Fuel Sampling Processes 325
Moshe Rabaev, Liel Mazar, Yalfal Siyum, Haim Judah, and Frederick J. Passman
Abstract To ensure flight safety, it is crucial to supply engines with the appropriate quality of fuel consistently. The fuel quality is verified through proper fuel sampling methods for field and laboratory testing. This chapter outlines official standards and reviews relevant literature on fuel sampling techniques, including tools and containers designed for various sampling points. The impact of local defects—such as poorly positioned sampling valves, sloping piping sections, or tilted vessels— on sampling accuracy is also examined. Further, the chapter explains methods for obtaining representative and indicative samples from fuel lines, tanks, and filters to diagnose specific issues. Special attention is given to the unique challenges asso-ciated with sampling from aircraft fuel tanks. The chapter also addresses incidents requiring sample collection for forensic analysis, detailing solutions for areas with limited access and sampling from ground-based and aircraft filters. Lastly, the chapter provides an in-depth discussion on sampling for microbiological testing, including the associated chain-of-custody documentation required for such tests.

12 Aviation Fuel and Fuel System Microbiology 367
Frederick J. Passman, Graham Hill, and Gareth Williams
Abstract Uncontrolled microbial contamination can cause or contribute to a number of problems in aviation fuels and fuel systems. The most common problems include fuel system biodeterioration, biofouling, and degradation of fuel properties. This chapter provides an overview of aviation fuel and fuel system microbiology, its detection, and its control.

13 Corrosion in Aviation Fuel Systems 415
Alec Groysman
Abstract Previous chapters shed light on crude sources and processing, additives, and microbiological growth in aviation fuels. Logically, they connect with corrosion. This chapter explains general principles and fundamentals of corrosivity of aviation fuels, how to control, monitor, and prevent corrosion of metallic parts (and partly polymers) in contact with aviation fuels.

14 Test Methods and Their Significance for Aviation Fuel Quality Testing 459
Konstantin Tartakovsky, Marlin D. Vangsness, and Moshe Rabaev
Abstract The remarkable safety of air travel compared to land transport is achieved through systematic risk management, failure investigation, and continuous improve-ment. A crucial area where these principles are applied is in preventing fuel system issues caused by aviation fuel contamination, which can pose acute and long-term risks during storage, transport, or use in aircraft fuel systems. Fuel quality assurance (QA) laboratories employ standardized protocols to ensure that aviation fuels comply with the specifications and limits defined in standard test methods and to detect many contaminants that can cause considerable short-term damage to the fuel system. However, routine analysis cannot identify numerous other contaminants that might severely damage the ground and aircraft fuel systems. In addition, to prevent re-contamination, the nature and source of the contamination must be determined. Where contamination is suspected, analytical chemistry laboratories have methods for deep fuel analyses that can meet these challenges. This chapter provides a general overview of some contaminants often found in fuels and suggests ways to detect them.

15 Aircraft Failure Analysis Induced by the Fuel or Fuel System 491
Albert Schmidt, Moshe Rabaev, Yalfal Siyum, Haim Judah, and Liel Mazar
Abstract This chapter provides a comprehensive analysis of aircraft failures induced by fuel or fuel system issues. The failures are categorized into four main types: fuel starvation, fuel exhaustion, fuel contamination, and wrong fuel usage. The chapter explores how these failures can lead to safety incidents or accidents, supported by real-world case studies. It highlights the importance of proper fuel system maintenance, monitoring, and adherence to safety regulations. The chapter also addresses the role of international regulatory bodies, such as the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), and national agencies, such as the Federal Avia-tion Administration (FAA) and the European Union Aviation Safety Agency (EASA), in setting certification standards for fuel systems. Despite global standards, compliance varies, and the chapter emphasizes the need for harmonized safety measures across jurisdictions. Additionally, the analysis delves into the risks posed by various contaminants—such as water, solids, and microbes—within fuel systems, and examines the dangers of using incorrect fuel types. The chapter concludes by stressing the crucial role of technical investigators and fuel engineers in conducting thorough failure analyses and implementing preventive measures to enhance aircraft safety.

Reviewers

The list of reviewers is every bit as illustrious as the list of authors. The following experts reviewed the book’s chapters:

David Abdallah, Dave Atwood, Elizabeth M. Bowman, Naphtali Brodsky, John Buffin, Jack Burgazli, Myrsini Chronopoulou, Jim Gammon, Tina Gleaves, Daniel E. Kadlecek, Jason Lee, Chris Lewis, Brenda Little, Madi Mohtadi, Micki Overberg, Paul Rawson, Francois Ropital, Joel Schmitigal, Stan Seto, and Ron Wilkinson.

Publication Details

DOIhttps://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-032-05514-9

  • Hardcover edition – ISBN 978-3-032-05513-2
  • Softcover edition – ISBN 978-3-032-05516-3
  • eBook – ISBN 978-3-032-05514-9
  • 565 pp
  • 26 black and white + 175 color illustrations

I know that I speak for my co-editors and the authors when I express my hope that this book will become a frequently used resource for aviation industry stakeholders.

THE CONTINUED IMPORTANCE OF MICROBICIDES IN INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS – REVISTED

ASIAN LUBRICANTS INDUSTRY ASSOSICATION (AILA) WEBINAR, 12 NOVEMBER 2025



Update

I’m reprinting my July 2024 What’s New article with an update. On 12 November 2025, I presented “The continued importance of antimicrobial pesticides for controlling microbial contamination in industrial process fluids and systems.” as an Asian Lubricants Industry Association (AILA) webinar. You can watch the webinar at https://vimeo.com/1136359576/92986256fc?share=copy&fl=sv&fe=ci.

The Challenge

At this year’s STLE Annual Meeting I presented a paper titled: “The continued importance of antimicrobial pesticides for controlling microbial contamination in industrial process fluids and systems.” Subsequently, the editors of Lube Magazine (https://www.lube-media.com/) invited me to write an article on the topic. That article – available from the Lube Media website only to Lube Magazine subscribers – was published in Lube Magazine, Issue 181, June 2024. I’ve also archived the article here on BCA’s website.

The crux of the issue is that for the past several decades, regulatory agencies have been increasingly myopic regarding the assessment of risks associated of biocidal products. The net effect has been a shrinking number of microbicidal active substances approved for use in Canada, Europe, the U.S., and other countries where microbicide use is regulated. The number of toxicological and environmental tests required to support new-product and registration renewal applications continues to grow as do end-use restrictions. For example, in 2000, the average cost for toxicological testing in support of industrial microbicide applications was less than $200,000 U.S. As of 2022, that average cost was between $1 million and $2 million U.S. The total global market for microbicides used in metalworking fluids (MWF) is estimated at $300 million U.S. Consequently, the potential return on investment no longer justifies the development of new active substances for controlling microbial contamination in MWF. Even the initial investment in toxicity testing to support product registrations is insufficient. All registered biocidal products are reviewed periodically for reregistration eligibility. In their 27 June 2008 Reregistration Eligibility Document (RED) for Hexahydro-1,3,5tris(2hydroxyethyl)-s-triazine (triazine), the U.S. EPA limited the maximum end-use dosage to 500 ppm – a dosage that’s less than the minimum concentration needed for triazine to work effectively. U.S. EPA’s OPP cited their concerns over formaldehyde exposure risk and their (incorrect) understanding of a 2023 paper.

Regulatory Agencies and Regulations

Table 1 lists selected regulatory agencies responsible for pesticide use oversight in the EU and specific countries, and the regulations under which the different agencies function. Within the EU, biocidal products approved by ECHAs Biocidal Products Committee (BPC) must also be approved the cognizant agencies of each country in which the products are sold. As for all products regulated under REACH, biocidal products are assessed based on their hazard (toxicological properties) rather than the risks associated with their use. Putatively, in the U.S., the U.S. EPA’s Office of Pesticide Programs (OPP) focuses on risk (the likelihood that users will suffer injuries). However, recent RED’s illustrate how OPP administrators tend to allow their understanding of hazard to trump the risk assessment (more on this below).

Table 1. National and Regional Agencies and Regulations Administering Microbicide Use.

Country/Region
Regulation
Agency
Canada Pest Control Products Act (PCPA) Pest Management Regulatory Agency (PMRA)
E.U. Biocidal Products Regulation (BPR) Biocidal Products Committee (BPC)
India Guidelines for the Registration of Biocide and Biocide Products Central Insecticide Board and Registration Committee (CIB&RC)
Japan Chemical Substances Control Law (CSCL) Ministry of Economy, Trade, and Industry (METI)
People’s Republic of China New Pesticide Management Regulation Institute for the Control of Agrochemicals, Ministry of Agriculture (ICAMA)
U.S. Federal Insecticide, Rodenticide, and Fungicide Act U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Pesticides Programs (U.S. EPA, OPP)

Note: a) This list illustrates the fact that globally there are numerous agencies responsible for regulating biocide use. It is not meant to be exhaustive.

The list of animal and ecotoxicological tests required varies by agency. In the U.S. an initial, relatively short list of toxicological tests are required in support of a pesticide application. The OPP representative reviewing the application can request additional tests. It is common for applicants to spend years incrementally supplying OPP with additional test results. Rather than either rejecting an application or providing the applicant with a compete list of additional tests that must be performed, OPP application reviewers tend to request additional tests, one at a time. For one product of which I am aware, the application for OPP approval for a product to be used in MWF has been going on for more than 15 years. In other instances, microbicide manufacturers had opted to withdraw heir products from the market rather than spend $ millions on additional toxicity, environmental fate and persistence, or both types of tests required in support of REDs. As a result, the number of microbicides available for use in MWF in the U.S. is <30 % of the number that were available in 1995. Similarly, in the EU, only 27 active substances are currently approved for use in MWF. That list was >200 in 1995.

Factors Driving Increased Regulatory Pressure

Hazard and risk conceptual conflation

You have no doubt seen variations of the meme in which a character is so focused on a relatively minor hazard that they are oblivious to a major one (Figure 1). A person backs away from a mouse and over a cliff, person is so focused on a bear cub that they remain unaware of the mama bear that’s about to attack – the examples go on. The issue is the same for the human tendency to conflate hazards with risks.


Fig 1. From the frying pan into the fire – person climbing the fence to escape the growling (petite) dog will undoubtedly not like the crocodiles waiting for him once he climbs over.

As I noted above, risk (R) is the likelihood (probability) that harm will occur. It is a function of hazard (H) and exposure (E), where hazard is the severity of harm likely to occur when the agent is contact, and exposure the degree of contact:

R = H x E      (1)

For chemical substances, hazard is assessed based on the doses at which different types of toxicological damage occur. Dosage for direct contact or ingestion is reported in mg of test substance per kg of test organism body weight (mg kg-1). For inhalation studies, it is reported as mg L-1 in the air the test organisms breath. Most commonly, the hazard measured is death, and the end point is the test substance concentration that kills half of the exposed population (lethal dose 50 – LD50 or lethal concentration – LC50). The acute tests that are required universally include:

  • Oral toxicity
  • Eye irritation
  • Dermal toxicity
  • Skin irritation
  • Inhalation toxicity
  • Skin sensitization

Other endpoints include tissue damage, impact on the test organisms’ metabolism, and other pathological symptoms. Acute toxicity tests measure the effect of a single exposure. Sub-chronic toxicity tests measure the effect of repeated exposures during a one-month test period. Chronic toxicity tests evaluate the test substance’s impact during the life of the test organism.

A chemical substance’s toxicity depends on its route of exposure. Figure 2a compares the acute oral toxicities of two chemicals I’ve designated as A and B. Figure 2b compares the acute dermal toxicities for the same two chemicals. Note that for oral toxicity, chemical A is more toxic than chemical B, but that for inhalation toxicity, B is more toxic than A. For chemical A, the oral LD50 = 200 mg kg-1 and the dermal LD50 is 1,000 mg L-1. Conversely, chemical B’s is more toxic through dermal contact than it is via the oral route.


Fig 2. Acute toxicity dose response curves – a) oral toxicity: substance A’s and B’s LD50 = 200 mg kg-1 and 750 mg kg-1, respectively; b) dermal toxicity: substance A’s and B’s LC50 = 1000 mg kg-1 and 100 mg kg-1, respectively.

In Figures 1a and 1b, none of the trend lines intersect with the Dose axis at 0 mg kg-1 or 0 mg L-1. The doses at which the trend lines intersect the Dose axis is called the no observable effect level (NOEL). Biological modeling plots toxicity test results to show the NOEL. Linear modelling forces the trend line through the origin (i.e., 0 % mortality at 0 mg kg-1 test substance concentration). If the four trendlines in Figure 1 were adjusted to go through the origin both test substances would appear to be more toxic than they actually are. The U.S. EPA uses the linear model to assess test substance toxicity. In other words, they tend to overestimate the hazard.

The second factor affecting risk is exposure. Exposure is a function of a substance’s concentration and the period of exposure. Being struck by a moving car is a hazard. The risk of being struck depends on the number of cars passing the exposed individual per unit of time (e.g., minute). In terms of cars passing per minute, in Figure 3 the couple walking on a country lane are exposed to a fraction of the cars to which the crowd walking on the freeway are. In industrial settings, without appropriate industrial hygiene controls in place (personal protective equipment, ventilation, etc.) workers handling concentrated chemicals potentially experience greater exposure than do workers exposed to diluted chemicals. However, when the workplace complies with hazardous material handling regulations, worker exposure is minimized.


Fig 3. Exposure – the couple on the left, walking on a country lane, are exposed to far fewer cars than are the people walking into a traffic-dense highway.

According to the Governors Highway Safety Association (GHSA), there were 7,485 pedestrians killed by moving vehicles in 2021. I’ll leave it for my readers to speculate how that statistic compares with the total number of industrial workers who have been killed by microbicide exposure in the past 100 years. When injuries have occurred, the cause has invariably failure to follow manufacturer’s handling instructions. The number of injuries associated with accidental exposure to non-biocidal chemicals is much greater than the number related to biocide exposure.

Narrow risk focus

Microbicides serve an important function. They are designed to control microbial contamination – they kill microorganisms. Globally, damage caused by microorganisms is estimated to cost hundreds of $ billions annually. These costs include spoilage (food, process fluids, specialty chemicals, paints and coatings, personal care products and countless other biodegradable materials), structural damage (primarily microbiologically influenced corrosion and biofouling), and health effects (allergies, toxemias, and infectious diseases). Microbicides play an essential role in reducing the health risks and other costs associated with microorganisms. However, regulatory agencies rarely consider the risks associated with not controlling microbiological contamination.

The formaldehyde issue

Currently, the U.S. EPA has targeted all formaldehyde-condensate microbicides for elimination. Their logic is:

Argument 1: Formaldehyde is a carcinogen.

Argument 2: Formaldehyde-condensate microbicides are manufactured by reacting formaldehyde with one or more other chemicals.

Argument 3: The mode of action of most formaldehyde-condensate microbicides is to release formaldehyde so that it can react with microorganisms’ structural and enzyme proteins.

Argument 4: If formaldehyde is released when formaldehyde-condensate microbicides kill microorganisms, it must also be released when those microbicides are diluted into treated fluids (e.g., metalworking fluids, paints, personal care products, etc.).

Therefore, people using formaldehyde-condensate microbicides are exposed to formaldehyde.

Unfortunately, this logic is flawed. The facts do not support argument 4. Modern analytical chemistry testing on fluids treated with formaldehyde-condensate microbicides have demonstrated that if any free-formaldehyde is present, it is at concentrations below detection levels (i.e., <1 μg kg-1 – ppb). Moreover, studies to test for formaldehyde in the air above formaldehyde-condensate microbicide treated and untreated metalworking fluids have determined that statistically there is no difference.

There’s a second flaw in the logic. The EPA recognizes that living beings produce formaldehyde. Except for the studies showing that formaldehyde concentrations in the air above untreated metalworking fluids were in the same range as above treated fluids, no research has reported the impact of uncontrolled microbial contamination on formaldehyde. Studies have also demonstrated that only formaldehyde-condensate microbicides denature endotoxins produced by Gram-negative bacteria that commonly grow in metalworking fluids. These last two considerations suggest that if formaldehyde-condensate microbicides can no longer be used in metalworking fluids, worker health risks due to endotoxin and other biological components (bioaerosols) would be greater than it is at present. It would be like rolling the microbial contamination control clock back to the 1960s when operators never had microbiological problems. Back then they only had odor problems.

In 1996, Lubrication Engineering published my paper: “Formaldehyde Risk in Perspective: A Toxicological Comparison of Twelve Biocides.” In that paper, I compared toxicity date for formaldehyde and a dozen MWF microbicides. The list included formaldehyde-condensates and nominally formaldehyde-free microbicides. In most test categories, the microbicidal products were less toxic than formaldehyde. None were either mutagenic or carcinogenic. Toxicity was not related to the presence of formaldehyde as a reactive intermediate.

The U.S. EPA has not been deterred by these facts. It is likely that formaldehyde-condensates will no longer be approved for use in MWF or other industrial applications.

Hysteria versus science

Equation 1 illustrated the relationship between hazard, risk, and exposure. It does not include the term that often overwhelms scientific assessment. That term is outrage. Outrage is the reaction individuals have to what they perceive to be unacceptable risk. This acceptability assessment is purely subjective. Risks that some people find totally acceptable, others find intolerable. Intolerance leads to outrage. Despite the well documented risks linked to smoking, the population of smokers consider the risk to be acceptable. Some non-smokers respond to secondary smoke exposure with outrage. Similarly, despite the nuclear power industry’s remarkable safety record, opponents of nuclear energy commonly react to proposed nuclear power generation facility construction proposals with outrage. Invariably, hard data are discarded when outrage appears. For biocides, it is the word itself rather than biocidal product toxicity that triggers outrage.

The words “biocide” or “microbicide” stimulate fear and anxiety even when the product’s toxicological data are more benign than those of other industrial chemicals. For example, in recent years a growing number of MWF compounders have been promoting biocide-free products. Some have been replacing traditional microbicides with an amine – dicyclohexylamine (DCHA). To date, the only published DCHA performance data demonstrate that it prevents uncontrolled microbial contamination from developing in MWF. Nothing has been reported about DCHA’s performance as a corrosion inhibitor, pH buffer, or other non-biocidal, functional additive. Figure 4 compares the acute oral, dermal, and inhalation toxicities of DCHA and hexahydro-1,3,5-tris(2-hydroxyethyl)-s-triazine (triazine – HHT). DCHA’s acute oral toxicity is 7x greater than HHT’s and its dermal toxicity is >10x that of HHT. Although HHT has a record of >70 years of safe, effective use, it is being replaced by a more toxic product that does not have a pesticide registration.


Fig 4. Toxicity comparison – dicyclohexylamine (DCHA) and hexahydro-1,3,5-tris(2-hydroxyethyl)-s-triazine (HHT).

A Rational Path Ahead

I have a simple proposition. Level the playing field. I suggest that governmental agencies responsible for industrial chemicals revise their regulations so that all industrial chemicals have the same data requirements for approval. Countless industrial chemicals are more toxic than those registered as biocidal products. Currently, the toxicological and environmental data available for many non-biocidal products are substantially more limited than data for biocidal products. Similarly, for a given chemical that has technical and biocidal uses, the amount of information required on a biocidal product’s label is substantially greater than on a technical product’s label (Figure 5).


Fig 5. Product labels for 10 % Sodium Hypochlorite (NaOCl – bleach) – a) label on household bleach bottle; b) master label for 10 % NaOCl as an algicide (22 pages).

Chemical substances’ adverse health effects are typically discovered only years after the general population has been exposed. If all products were required to be supported by the same toxicity and environmental data, manufacturers would lose their incentive to replace approved biocidal products with potentially more toxic substitutes.

Summary

Microbicides are under increasing regulatory pressure. This pressure translates into an increased number of tests requires in support of registration and reregistration applications. The additional tests are substantially more expensive than those run for technical grade chemicals and typically add up to more than $2 million U.S. These costs have a chilling impact against new microbicide development. The greater toxicity testing burden for biocidal products does not reflect either increased exposure risk or chemical hazard. It is based on hysterical reactions to the word biocide. The unintended consequences of this trend will be increased health risks and biodeterioration costs.

I look forward to your thoughts and questions about how industry stakeholders can reverse this shrinking availability of biocidal products. Contact me at fr***@**********************ol.com.

MICROBIOLOGY FOR THE UNITINTIATED – PART 9: ARCHAEA


Mats of Archaea on surface of Morning Glory hot spring, Yellowstone Park, WY. Source: 440px-Morning-Glory_Hotspring.jpg (440×328)

Introduction

From the 1860s through the 1970s, the tree of life was grouped into three domains – Plantae, Protista, and Animalia1 (Figure 1).


Fig 1. Simplified phylogenic tree based on Haeckel, 1866.

The Archaea were first discovered in thermal springs where the water temperature was nearly 100 °C (212 °F). Because their general shape (morphology) and size was like that of bacteria (Figure 2), and they lived in extreme environments that were thought to reflect those of Earth, more than 3 billion years ago, the Archaea were initially classified as “ancient” bacteria – Archaebacteria. Early investigators recognized that the isolates form extreme environments had some unique properties. They interpreted these properties as evidence that the Archaebacteria were the earliest forms of life. The logic was reasonable.

  • Archaea were (initially) only recovered from extreme environments that resembled early Earth, and

  • Archaea were apparently all chemolithotrophic or chemoheterotrophic anaerobes (see What’s New, 31 May 2023).


Fig 2. Prokaryotes – a) Archaea sp.; b) Bacteria (Pseudomonas sp.).

In time, both of these points turned out to be wrong.

In 1977, Carl Woese and George E Fox at the University of Illinois at Champaign Urbana proposed a major revision to the tree of life. They postulated that genetic material – particularly ribonucleic acid (RNA) – could be used as an evolutionary clock. Differences in RNA from different organisms could be used to estimate when they split off from the last universal common ancestor (LUCA2). They also found that the RNA of Archaea was sufficiently different from that of bacteria to make the Archaea a kingdom of its own. Woese and Fox used the term Archaebacteria (from archaeon – ancient – and bacteria). As illustrated in Figure 3a, speculated that microbes in this kingdom were more ancient than the “true bacteria” (Eubacteria or Bacteria). Subsequent research has demonstrated that the Archaea are less ancient than the Bacteria (Figure 3b). In addition to their unique properties, they share some common characteristics with Bacteria and others with Eukaryotes.

Archaea remain difficult to culture, although ~150 different Archaea taxa of the >2,000 taxa identified by metagenomics have now been grown in laboratories. Consequently, most of what is known about them has been determined by non-culture techniques. The original theory about all Archaea being extremophiles – requiring extreme environments such as high (>45 °C) or low temperature (<0 °C), salinity (brine), pressure (>10 kPa; 100 ATM), pH in the <1 or >11 range, or combinations of two or more of these conditions – reflected limited data rather than reality. Archaea have been recovered from many non-extreme environments; including industrial systems. Moreover, representatives of all of the physiological categories listed in Table 1 of my May 2023 What’s New post have been identified among the Archaea. Since they were first discovered in extreme environments, Archaea have been recovered in diverse ecosystems. They are as ubiquitous as bacteria.


Fig 3. Two simplified phylogenic tree of life models – a) after Woese and Fox (1990); b) current model.

Archaea Phylogeny

Taxonomy and phylogeny are two approaches to categorizing organisms. Whereas taxonomy is based on the comparison of observable characteristics (plant versus animal, exoskeleton – shell – versus endoskeleton – bones; etc.), phylogeny attempts to categorize organisms based on their evolutionary relationships. Historically, biologists had no choice but to rely on taxonomy to classify organisms. The Woese and Fox evolutionary clock concept made it possible to rely on phylogenic methods (i.e., genomics) to classify organisms based on their genetic similarities. That said, in the arena of Archaeal phylogeny it is reasonable to paraphrase the words of former Secretary of State, Donald Rumsfeld, when he mentioned the unknown unknowns – those things we don’t know that we don’t know. Figure 4 illustrates a recent phylogenic tree for Archaea, but the model is not universally accepted and is likely to continue to be modified as researchers learn more about the Archaea. Note that the lengths of the lines and points where lines branch off in Figure 4 reflect genetic relationships among the different taxa.


Fig 4. Phylogenic tree of Domain Archaea depicting five phyla (Source: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/274708754_Archaea_Morphology_Physiology_Biochemistry_and_Applications)

The phylum Euryarchaeota includes methanogens (Archaea able to produce methane form hydrogen and carbon dioxide or acetate), halophilic taxa (Archaea that thrive in saturated salt brine), and some extreme thermophiles (some of which grow at >120 °C – >248 °F). Thus far Nanoarchaeota includes only one species – Nanoarchaeum equitans – an organism that was discovered near a deep-sea thermal vent. N. equitans is nominally spherical, and as its name implies, is <0.6 μm diameter. Similarly, the Korarchaeota thus far includes only a single genus of extremely thermophilic archaea. Crenarchaeota were initially recovered from thermal springs and thought to be acidophilic (thriving in pH 2 to 4 water), thermophilic organisms. Subsequently Crenarchaeota genera were discovered to be ubiquitous in marine sediments and freshwater environments. In 2005, an ammonia oxidizing species was recovered from a marine aquarium tank. The Thaumarchaeota (AKA Nitrososphaerota) primarily includes ammonia oxidizers.

Archaeal Cell Morphology

One distinguishing feature of archaeal cells is their unique cell wall and membrane chemistries. As illustrated in Figure 5, unlike bacterial and eukaryotic cell membranes that are comprised of D-glycerol, ester-linked lipids, archaeal cell membranes have branched tailed, ether-linked, L-glycerol lipids. Archaeal cell walls are comprised of S-layer proteins or pseudopeptidoglycan (N-acetylglucosamine and N-acetyltalosaminuronic acid) or S-layer proteins, but no peptidoglycan. All bacterial cell walls have a peptidoglycan layer (Figure 6).


Fig 5. Schematic drawings of Archaeal cell membrane phospholipids (top) and those of bacteria and Eukaryotes (Source: https://cdn.kastatic.org/ka-perseus-images/9d44a501fb30b8301640773ed409226119208fdf.png).

Morphologically, the Archaea are quite diverse. Their size ranges from <1 μm to >150 μm. Their geometry can be spherical, obround, or spiraled. Some methanogens are disk-shaped and some thermophiles have irregular shapes (Figure 7).

Comparing Archaea and Bacteria


Fig 6. Schematic illustration of the supramolecular architecture of the major classes of prokaryotic cell envelopes containing surface (S) layers. S-layers in archaea with glycoprotein lattices as exclusive wall component are composed either of mushroom-like subunits with pillar-like, hydrophobic trans-membrane domains (a), or lipid-modified glycoprotein subunits (b). Individual S-layers can be composed of glycoproteins possessing both types of membrane anchoring mechanisms. Few archaea possess a rigid wall layer (e.g. pseudomurein in methanogenic organisms) as intermediate layer between the plasma membrane and the S-layer (c). In Gram-positive bacteria (d) the S-layer glycoproteins are bound to the rigid peptidoglycan-containing layer via secondary cell wall polymers. In Gram-negative bacteria € the S-layer is closely associated with the lipopolysaccharide of the outer membrane (Source: Sleytr UB, et al. (2014). “S-layers: Principles and Applications”. FEMS Microbiology Reviews. 38 (5): 823–864. doi:10.1111/1574-6976.12063).


Fig 7. Diversity of Archaeal cell morphologies – a) Brightfield image of the triangular-shaped Haloarcula japonica cells; b – The square and flat Haloquadratum walsbyi cells with DNA stained with acridine orange; c – contrast-phase of rods and “golf clubs” cells of Thermoproteus tenax; d – Scanning electron micrograph image of multicellular clusters of the coccoid Methanosarcina spp. Culture from environmental samples; e – Cryoelectron tomograph of a Thermococcus kodakaraensis cell showing a conical basal body (bottom structure) anchoring the archaellum (top structure) to the cytoplasm; f – Electron micrograph of the cold-living SM1 euryarchaeon showing several pili-like hami fibers around the entire cell surface; g – Electron micrograph of a section of a filamentous hamus showing its hook (tip) and prickle (body) structures (Source: Bisson-Filho et al. (2018), https://doi.org/10.1091/mbc.E17-10-0603).

Table 1 summarizes other similarities and differences between Archaea and Bacteria. Archaea also share characteristics with Eukaryotes.

Table 1. Comparisons between Archaea and Bacteria

Property Archaea Bacteria
Cell type Prokaryote Prokaryote
Cellular organization Single cell (unicellular) Single cell
Cell organelles No membrane-bound internal structures (organelles) No membrane-bound internal structures
Chromosomes Circular (like Bacteria); transcription & translation like Eukaryotes Circular; unique transcription & translation
Horizontal gene transfer (HGT) Many taxa exhibit HGT HGT is rare
Histone and histone-like proteins Present Absent
Intronsa Present (also in Eukaryotes) Absent
Ribosomal RNA (rRNA) rRNA sequences unique to Archaea rRNA sequences different than for Archaea
Reproduction Fission (asexual) Fission
RNA polymerase enzymes Multiple & complex (like Eukaryotes) Single enzyme

Ecological Significance

Based on their ubiquity and metabolic diversity in terms of energy metabolism (autotrophy – using carbon dioxide as their energy source, chemolithotrophy – using ammonia, sulfide, or other inorganic molecules as their energy source, photolithotropy – obtaining energy from sunlight) Archaea play important roles in carbon, nitrogen, and sulfur biogeochemical cycles (biogeochemical cycles are the natural processes by which nutrient elements move between organisms and the environment – I’ll discuss biogeochemical cycles in the next several What’s New articles). Methanogenesis plays an important role in anaerobic sewage sludge digestion. Methane captured from digesters and landfills is used for power generation and in gas-powered vehicles. Recent research has suggested that Archaea comprise >20 % of the total biomass in marine environments. Again, they play critical roles in biogeochemical cycling in marine sediments. It is likely that they play similar roles in other aquatic ecosystems.

Are Archaea Biodeteriogenic?

Earlier, I paraphrased the third part of Secretary Rumsfeld’s “unknowns” quote. The answer to the question of whether Archaea are biodeteriogenic evokes the second part of the quote: “There are known unknowns. That is to say there are things we now know that we do not know.” For most of the history of microbiological contamination condition monitoring, the primary tool has been culture testing. As with every other tool for detecting and quantifying microbiological contamination, culture testing has benefits and limitations. Recognizing that nutrient media and incubation conditions routinely used for routine culture testing do not detect Archaea, until recently, Archaea have remained undetected in industrial systems. Archaea abundance, distribution, and metabolic activities in industrial systems remain known unknowns. Until recently, the cost of genomic testing was prohibitive for routine condition monitoring. As commercially available test kits at relatively modest cost have become available the potential to learn about whether or how Archaea contribute to biodeterioration has become feasible. The presence of Archaea in petroleum formations has been well documented. To date, there have been only a few reports of Archaea in fuels, metalworking fluids, and other industrial systems. Consequently, although it is reasonable to speculate that Archaea play a role in biodeterioration, there is no concrete evidence to support that speculation. In the flip side, a growing number of researchers are investigating the use of Archaea in fuel cells.

Summary

The Archaea were identified as a unique biological domain only 45 years ago. Initially, their distribution in nature was believed to be restricted to extreme environments such as hot springs, acid mine drainage streams, and salt evaporation ponds. Their ubiquitous distribution and essential role in nutrient cycling has only been recognized in the past two decades. The tools for detecting Archaea as part of routine condition monitoring programs are only now becoming available. Industries in which microbiology expertise is rare and reliance on the oldest test methods is the norm are unlikely to develop substantial data on Archaea distribution or abundance. Consequently, much remains to be learned about whether or how Archaea contribute to biodeterioration.

As always, please share your comments and questions with me at fr***@**********************ol.com.


1 Árbol de la vida según Haeckel, E. H. P. A. (1866).Generelle Morphologie der Organismen : allgemeine Grundzüge der organischen Formen-Wissenschaft, mechanisch begründet durch die von C. Darwin reformirte Decendenz-Theorie. Berlin.

2 Weiss, Madeline C.; Sousa, F. L.; Mrnjavac, N.; et al. (2016). “The physiology and habitat of the last universal common ancestor” (PDF). Nature Microbiology. 1 (9): 16116.

MICROBIOLOGY FOR THE UNITINTIATED – PART 8: ALGAE


Algal growth coating cooling tower backfill.
Source: https://petapixel.com/2016/10/13/photos-reveal-guts-massive-cooling-towers/

Introduction

Today’s post continues my survey of microorganisms that commonly infect industrial systems. Algae are photosynthetic members of the Domain Eukarya, Kingdom Protista. Taxonomically and genetically diverse, all algae are photosynthetic (although some can obtain their energy through chemoheterotrophic metabolism – see What’s New, May 2023). The one common feature of all algae is the presence of chloroplasts (see below). Morphologically, algae range from single cells (unicellular) microalgae (e.g., Chlorella species, dia < 100 μm, Figure 1a) to multicellular, giant kelp (Macrocystis pyrifera, which can grow to 200 m long, Figure 1b). Given that all but one genus of algae are photosynthetic, algal contamination is only problematic in systems exposed to light. Most commonly these are cooling towers (title photo).


Fig 1. Algal diversity – a) Chlorella species; b) Macrocystis pyrifera.

Agal Taxonomy

There’s still considerable debate about taxonomic classification which still uses the system Carl Linnaeus developed during the 16th century. One classification (Figure 2), proposed in 2008, assigns algae to seven Divisions, based on:

  • Gross morphology (algal body – unicellular, multicellular, branched or unbranched thalli, etc.)
  • Primary cell wall chemical composition
  • Types of chlorophyll and carotenoids
  • Phycobiliproteins
  • Storage products.


Fig 2. Algal Divisions, after Lee (Phycology, 4th ed. Cambridge University Press, London, ISBN 10-9780521682770).

Notes:

  1. Chlorophyta can be unicellular or multicellular. The latter can be mononucleated, coenocytic (>1 nucleus per cell), and form branching or non-branching filaments.
  2. Chl a and Chl b – Chlorophyll a and Chlorophyll ; the chlorophyll types involved in photosynthesis.
  3. Neg. – Phycobiliproteins are only found in Rhodophyta.
  4. CHO – carbohydrates.

I have not seen a more recent, genomics-based taxonomy. It will be interesting to see how alga taxonomy changes when relationships among taxa are assessed based on genetics rather than traditional tools.

Except for diatoms, which are members of the Division, Bacillariophyta, the algae most commonly recovered from cooling towers are all members of the Division, Chlorophyta. Figure 3 illustrates examples of algae most commonly recovered from cooling tower systems.


Fig 3. Algae commonly recovered from cooling systems – a) Chlorella sp.; b) Diatoms; c) Oocysts; d) Pediastrum sp.; E) Scenedesmus sp.

Agal Cell Morphology

Figure 4 shows a simplified sketch of an algal cell. Except for algae in the Divisions Chlorophyta and Euglenophyta, all algal cells have cell walls. Cell wall chemistries differ among the algae Divisions. The cell wall functions primarily to maintain cell form and structural integrity. It also maintains the cell membrane’s integrity. The cell membrane regulates the movement of nutrients, salts, and other substances between the cell and its environment. The cytoplasm is a complex, gel-like substance that contains the cell’s organelles. The primary organelles are the nucleus, mitochondria, ribosomes, and chloroplasts. As with all other eukaryotic organisms, the nucleus contains the cell’s chromosomal deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA). It also contains the nucleolus – the site of ribosomal ribonucleic acid (rRNA) production.

Ribosomes are the sites of protein production. Messenger RNA (mRNA) takes (transcribes) coding from DNA in the nucleus and transports it to the ribosomes. Within the ribosomes mRNA transfers the code to rRNA which then aligns transfer RNA (tRNA) to which amino acids are attached. Thus, the DNA’s gene sequence dictates the order in which amino acids are assembled into proteins. Mitochondria are the organelles in energy metabolism is centered. The citric acid cycle (also known as the tricarboxylic acid cycle) catabolizes macronutrients (alcohols, carbohydrates, fats, and proteins) to produce Acetyl-CoA. Acetyl-CoA oxidation generates adenosine triphosphate (ATP) – which, as I have discussed elsewhere, is the cell’s “coin of the realm” for energy metabolism. Mitochondria also function to regulate cell metabolism, control cell signally, heat generation (thermogenesis), and death (apoptosis). Chloroplasts are the organelles in which chlorophyll and carotenoids convert solar energy and carbon dioxide into chemical energy (ATP) and organic molecules (sugars, amino acids, and lipids. Chloroplasts and mitochondria evolved from independent prokaryotes to intracellular symbionts (i.e., microbes living within other organisms’ cells to the mutual benefit of both) to organelles. The storage products listed in the bottom row of Figure 2 are stored in the cell’s vacuoles.


Fig 4. Algal cell simplified diagram.

Biodeteriogenic Activity

Heat exchange inhibition

Algae growing on heat exchanger surfaces form insulating masses (biofilms) that can reduce heat exchange dramatically. Figure 5 shows four examples of algal masses coating heat exchanger surfaces. Figure 6 illustrates the relationship between biofilm thickness and heat exchange efficiency through three metals (carbon steel, stainless steel, and copper). A 10 μm thick biofilm can decrease heat exchange though carbon steel, stainless steel and copper by 22 %, 31 %, and 80 %, respectively.


Fig 5. Algal biofilms of four heat exchanger surfaces.


Fig 6. Relationship between biofilm thickness and heat transfer for three metals.
(Source: https://aquariustech.com.au/wp-content/uploads/bsk-pdf-manager/Biofilm_and_Energy_Loss_3.pdf)

Building deterioration

Except for aquatic structures such as pier foundations (Figure 7a), algae typically grow as aerophytes (organisms that obtain moisture and nutrients from the air, rather than from the substrates on which they are growing) on buildings and other structures (Figure 7b through 7e). Algae can grow on structure surfaces (epiphytic growth), in the pores of those surfaces (endophytic growth), or both. Algal growth on structure surfaces affects their aesthetics. When the effect is deemed negative it is called aesthetical biodeterioration. In addition to the aesthetic impact, aerophytic algae can increase the water absorptive capacity of the structure – thereby increasing its susceptibility to expansion and contraction due to freezing and thawing of the trapped water. Algal biofilms create habitats for biodeteriogenic bacteria and fungi. Organic acids produced by algal biofilm communities also decrease the pH of interstitial water absorbed by the structures on which they grow. The end result in loss of structural integrity.


Fig 7. Structure biodeterioration caused by algae – a) concrete pier, India; b) stone wall, Palas du Roi, Spain; c) brick wall; d) house siding; e) statue, Courances castle, France.

Harmful algal blooms

Harmful algal blooms (HAB) occur when aquatic environments are enriched with nitrogen and phosphorus nutrients – stimulating the rapid proliferation of one or more algal species. Most commonly, the algal biomass becomes sufficiently thick to block sunlight from reaching plants below the surface (Figure 8). As the algae in the bloom die off, they provide nutrients for heterotrophic bacteria. Although algae produce oxygen, the rate of oxygen consumption through respiration can exceed the rate of oxygen generation. When this occurs, the body of water eutrophication occurs (Figure 8). The oxygen concentration becomes depleted, causing marine life to suffocate (Figure 9d).


Fig 8. Eutrophication


Fig 9. Harmful algal blooms – a) freshwater pond; b) lakeshore; c) pond, showing CO2 gas bubbles forming on water surface; d) fish asphyxiated by algal bloom.

Red tides are a form of HAB. The algae most commonly found in red tides are dinoflagellates and diatoms. Table 1 lists several dinoflagellates associated with red tides. The Table also lists the toxins that these algae produce. Most of the toxins listed are neurotoxins that accumulate in shellfish tissue and cause paralytic shellfish poisoning. Figure 9 shows two examples of red tides.

Table 1. Red tide dinoflagellates and their toxins.

Genus Toxins
Alexandrium Carbomoyltoxins: saxitoxin (STX), neosaxitoxin (NEO), and C-11 O-sulfated analogues gonyautoxins (GTX1-GTX4); N-21 sulfocarbamoyl analogues (B1=GTX5, B2= GTX6, C1-C4)
Amoebophyra Parasitic; no toxin
Ceratium None
Chattonella Gonyautoxins 2/3 (GTX2/3), decarcarbamoyl (dcSTX, dcGTX2/3), and sulfocarbamoyl toxins (B1 and C1/2)
Cochlodinium Allelopathic chemicals
Dinophysis Okadaic acid, dinophysistoxins, and pectenotoxin
Gonyaulax Yessotoxins
Gymnodinium N-sulfocarbamoyl analogues (C1–4), gonyautoxin 5 (GTX5), gonyautoxin 6 (GTX6), and decarbamoyl derivatives, decarbamoyl saxitoxin (dcSTX), decarbamoyl neosaxitoxin (dcNeo) and decarbamoyl gonyautoxin 3 (dcGTX3); hydroxy benzoate derivatives, G. catenatum toxin 1 (GC1), GC2 and GC3; two presumed N-hydroxylated analogues of GC2 and GC3, designated GC5 and GC6.
Karena Brevetoxins PbTx-2 and PbTx-3
Noctiluca None


Fig 10. Red tides – a) Karenia brevis off the Florida coast; b) Noctiluca scintillans off the Washington coast.

Summary

Algae are phylogenetically diverse photosynthetic organisms that range in size from <100 μm unicellular diatoms to multicellular giant kelp (50 m to 200 m long). In industry, algae adversely affect heat exchange and fluid flow in cooling water systems. Algal biomass can also clog tricking bed wastewater treaters. As primary oxygen producers, algal growth is generally beneficial. However, harmful algal blooms can cause eutrophication – creation of oxygen depleted zones on lakes and ponds – and produce toxins that can be lethal to fish and marine mammals. Humans who eat shellfish in which algal toxins have become concentrated, can experience fatal paralytic shellfish poisoning.

As always, please share your comments and questions with me at fr***@**********************ol.com.

INTERNATIONAL BIODETERIORATION & BIODEGRADATION SYMPOSIUM 19 – BERLIN


Bundesanstalt für Materialforschung und -prüfung – 87 Unter den Eichen Entrance

Returning to BAM After 46 Years

In the book of Ecclesiastes (1:9), we read: “there is nothing new under the sun.”

In 1978, the International Biodeterioration & Biodegradation Society (IBBS) – then known as the Biodeterioration Society (BS) – held International Biodeterioration Symposium 4 (IBS4) at Bundesanstalt für Materialforschung und -prüfung (BAM – ~15 km SW of Berlin’s center). In September 2024 we returned to BAM for International Biodeterioration & Biodegradation Symposium 19 (IBBS19).

With a gap of 46 years between the two events, I thought it might be interesting to compare the two symposia. Full disclosure, shortly after I became IBBS’s president, Shiela Barry (Honorary Secretary, The Standing Committee for International Biodeterioration Symposia – SCIBS – 1976 – 1978), sent me two packages of IBBS historical documents. I opened the first package after returning home from IBBS19 and discovered that one of Shiela’s packages contained a binder filled with a 3 cm thick stack of documents related to IBS4 planning efforts.

As I read through the package of documents that Sheila had sent, I was struck by how – except for the originator and addressee names – how the missives sent in 1978 were remarkably similar to those that were exchanged among IBBS19’s planners. There was one other substantial difference. All of the 1976 through 1978 missives were either handwritten or typed manually and mailed through post offices (remember snail mail?). All of the 2022 through 2024 missives were either emails or attachments to emails – electronic files.

In 1978, David R. Houghton was the SCIBS Chairman (recall that 1978 predated current usage of Chair, etc.) and Sheila Barry was Secretary. H. C. Günther Becker – representing BAM – served as Chairman, International Biodeterioration Symposium 4 (IBS4). IBS4 was held from 28 August to 01 September 1978. IBBS no longer has an SCIBS. IBBS19 was managed by DECHEMA-Forschungsinstitut (DECHMA). With Matthew Neuman representing DECHMA, this was the first IBBS symposium that was not managed entirely by society volunteers. The symposium planning committee chairs, Andrea Kordt and Hans-Jörg Kunte, represented BAM and led a planning committee that included subject matter experts representing various biodeterioration topics (Figure 1)


Fig 1. IBBS19 Planning Committee members. Left to right, front row: Andrea Kordt (Chair), Sara Taghavi Kalajahi, Kequin Wen, Andre de Araujo Abilio; middle row: Archismita Misra, Gabriela Alfaro Espinosa, Michelle Unger; back row: Lydia Sobisch, Niclas Nordholt, Orestis Kanaris, Ruben Gerrits

A group photo from 1978 (Figure 2a) shows that approximately 40 people attended IBS4. More than tree times that number (Figure 2b) attended IBBS19. Moreover, scientists and engineers from 25 countries joined us at BAM for IBBS19.

The casual observer is likely to notice two differences among the 1978 IBS4 and 2024 IBBS19 groups. The 2024 gender ratio is much closer to parity than it was in 1978. There were only four women in the 1978 photo. In distinct contrast, nearly 50 % of the IBBS19 attendees were women. Moreover, the close observer will be hard pressed to find with a tie or jacket amongst the IBBS19 attendees.


Fig 2. IBS4 and IBBS19 attendees – a) 1978 IBS4 group photo; b) 2024 IBBS19 attendees during plenary session.

The gender equality is also reflected in the composition of the IBBS Council. Figure 3 shows the current Council members who attended IBBS19.


Fig 3. Left to right – Andrea Koerdt, Judit Kinz, Thomas Warscheid, Fred Passman, Jonathan Butler, Clara Urzi, Ji-Dong Gu, Joanna Verran, Scott Mitchell.

Figure 4 compares the 1978 and 2024 programs. Although the programs share many similar topics, IBBS19’s program was rich in molecular microbiological methods. Back in 1978 most research depended on culture methods. Additionally, topics such as sustainability and resource security were not on the 1978 agenda. That said, both programs focused on researched aimed to understand and mitigate biodeterioration of infrastructure and cultural objects – thet latter ranging from archival material (books and other documents) to architectural and archaeological structures.


Fig 4. 1978 IBS4 and 2024 IBBS19 programs.

In 1978, few researchers were investigating biofilms. This year, a half-day roundtable program focused on the need to standardize biofilm research approaches. It’s challenging to reach consensus on the appropriate balance between the need for new methods development and standardization that makes it possible to compare results obtained by different research teams. As I have written previously, IBBS maintains an annotated list of consensus standards related to biodeterioration testing (Consensus-Standards-September-2024.pdf). This list includes standards from AMMP (formerly NACE), ASTM, EI, and IBRG. If you are aware of other consensus standards organizations who have developed standards relevant to biodeterioration, please let me know and I’ll update the list.

I couldn’t resist comparing the registration costs for the 1978 and 2024 symposia. The IBS4 registration fee was a mere ₤60. For IBBS19, IBBS members paid 620 € (early registration). However, the 2024 value of ₤60 in 1978 ₤s = ₤590 = €708). Thus, IBBS24 was a bargain relative to IBS4!

Except for the year – 2027 – IBBS Council has yet to confirm either the dates or venue for IBBS20. I’ll share that information as it becomes available.

Having joined the Biodeterioration Society in 1984, I missed IBS4. I am indebted to Shiela Barry for both the documents and insights she has shared about our society’s early days. Now that I can count myself among the long-term members of IBBS, throughout IBBS19 I was delighted by both the number of young researchers (students and individuals who received their degrees within the past five years) who attended the symposium. It portends a bright future for biodeterioration and bioremediation research.

RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN TWO BIOBURDEN TESTS IN FUELS AND FUEL-ASSOCIATED WATERS


Left: ATP Test kit supplies; Center: PhotonMaster luminometer for ATP luminometry; Right: GeneCount E-32 apparatus for qPCR (Images courtesy of LuminUltra Technologies, Ltd., Fredericton, NB, Canada).

New Publication

The relationship between microbial population ATP and quantitative PCR bioburdens in diesel fuel microcosms (Access Microbiology 2024;6:000695.v4) was published last month. I’ll start this post by thanking my co-authors Dr. Jordan Schmidt and Ms. Danika Nicoletti, both of LuminUltra Technologies Ltd, Fredericton, NB, Canada) for their collaboration and the Coordinated Research Council (CRC) for funding the study from which we obtained our samples.

Measuring Bioburden

In my July 2017 post (Fuel System Microbiology Part 12 – Test Methods – Microbiological Tests), I provided an overview of the primary groups of test methods available for measuring microbiological contamination levels (bioburdens) in fuels and other industrial process fluids. I continued the overview in Fuel System Microbiology Part 13 – Test Methods – More on Microbiological Tests. In his book, “The Structure of Scientific Revolutions,” historian and science philosopher Thomas S. Kuhn (1922 to 1996) opined: “The answers you get depend on the questions you ask.” I wrote about this in my second July 2017 post. No test method is universally better than other available methods. Each approach has advantages and limitations relative to the alternative methods, depending on the information one is attempting to obtain.

For diagnostic testing, my preference is to use several different methods. Traditionally, I have used chemical microbiology methods such as catalase activity or – since 2009 – cellular adenosine triphosphate concentration ([cATP]) and various culture tests. More recently, I’ve begun to augment these tests with quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) testing. Chemical tests such as [cATP] by ASTM Test Method D7687 assess metabolically active bioburdens. Although the actual [cATP] per microorganism varies considerably due to each microbe’s genetics and physiology, hundreds of studies performed since 1954, have consistently reported that in environmental samples, [cATP] = 1 pg mL-1 ≈ 1,000 cells mL-1 (1 pg = 10-12 g). However, ATP testing only detects metabolically active microorganisms. Moreover, it does not identify the types of microorganisms present in the sample. Traditionally, culture testing (for example ASTM Practice D6974 and Test Method D7978) provided the only means of identifying the types of microbes present. Microbes that reproduced in or on nutrient media could be isolated and tested further for taxonomic identification. Moreover, microbes that were dormant in environmental samples, could recover and form colonies on nutrient media. This latter capability could be viewed as an advantage for detecting inactive microorganisms that could potentially cause problems if they became metabolically active. It could also be viewed as a disadvantage because dormant microbes that generated positive culture test results might not actually be causing problems. The risk was time and expense responding to non-existent problems.

Culture testing remains the only practical tool for obtaining pure cultures on which to perform certain types of studies. However, genomic testing has become an increasingly valuable tool for quantifying specific types of microbe present in samples. ASTM Guide D8412 provides an overview of qPCR testing. I’ll provide more details below. Here, I’ll simply indicate that qPCR can be used to assess broad groups of microbes (e.g., total prokaryotes – bacteria and archaea, or total eukaryotes – fungi, protozoa, etc.) or individual taxa (I suspect that few readers have not been tested for the SARS-CoV-2 virus – COVID – by qPCR). As with all genomic tests, qPCR depends on quantitative extraction of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) from all of the microorganisms in the specimen. Additionally, qPCR does not distinguish between dormant and metabolically active microorganisms. However, qPCR – now available as a field test – can provide quantitative data within a few hours. Depending on the type of microbe to be detected, culture testing can require two to 30-days or longer before final results are available.

ATP and qPCR Common Steps

Both test methods start off with similar steps. As Illustrated in Figure 1,

  • Microbes are concentrated and separated from the sample (i.e., fuel, fuel-associated water, etc.) by filtration.
  • For ATP testing, potentially interfering chemicals are washed away. This step is not needed for qPCR.
  • For ATP testing, microbial cells are lysed (broken open) to release their contents. For qPCR cells at not lysed until after they have been resuspended from filter.
  • Retain stable extract in appropriate buffer.

The resulting extract includes all of the biomolecules that were originally present inside the intact microorganisms.


Fig 1. Initial steps for biomolecule testing – A) ATP testing – 1) microorganisms are separated from sample and concentrated by filtering through a glass fiber filter; 2) chemicals that can interfere with assay are washed away; 3) cleaned cells are lysed and their contents are captured in a test tube; 4) extract is preserved in dilution buffer. B) qPCR – 1) and 2) microorganisms are separated from sample and concentrated by filtering through an in-line filter; 3) filter is removed from housing and folded; 4) filter is suspended in preservation buffer.

ATP Test

For ATP testing by ASTM Test Method D7687, the extract is diluted into a reagent that neutralizes any residual wash or extraction reagent that could interfere with the assay. A 100 μL specimen of diluted extract is reacted with 100 μL of Luciferin-Luciferase reagent in a cuvette. The cuvette in placed into a luminometer (device designed to detect the photons of light generated when a molecule of ATP reacts with Luciferin enzyme and Luciferase substrate as summarize in Figure 2). Because every luminometer is unique, the raw results are in relative light units (RLU). The RLU from test specimens are compared against those from a 1 ng mL-1 ATP reference standard to convert RLU to cellular ATP concentration ([cATP]) in pg mL-1.


Fig 2. ATP-mediated Luciferin Luciferase reaction- a) Luciferian + ATP + O2 react enzymatically with; b) Luciferase Enzyme and Mg2+ co-factor to produce; c) Oxyluciferin + AMP + (PO4)2 (pyrophosphate) + CO2 + a photon of light.

qPCR Test

For qPCR testing, DNA is extracted from the filter through a sequence of steps that includes cell lysis, and DNA purification. The specimen DNA is resuspended in a buffer (Figure 3) and reagents that include deoxynucleotides (deoxyadenosine triphosphate – dATP, deoxycytidine triphosphate – dCTP, deoxyguanosine triphosphate – dGTP, and deoxythymidine – dTTP), DNA-polymerase, oligonucleotide primers, and a fluorescent dye (Figure3, A, B, C, and D, respectively) are added to a microcentrifuge tube (Figure 3 E) containing the specimen DNA. As shown in the Figure 3 photograph, the cuvette is then placed into an apparatus that runs a series of heating and cooling cycles to alternately denature the specimen DNA (Figure 4a), allow the primers to attached to any matching nucleotide sequences (i.e., genes) on each of the DNA single strands created by the denaturation step (Figure 4b), and allow new double stranded DNA to form (Figure 4c). The amount of DNA that contains the target gene(s) doubles with each thermal cycle (Figure 4d).


Fig 3. qPCR sample handling – A) deoxynucleotides (dATP, dCTP, dGTP, and dTTP); B) Taq-polymerase; C) 16s RNA primers; D) SYBR Green fluorescent dye; E) DNA specimen in buffer. Photo: Six microcentrifuge tubes being placed into qPCR apparatus.


Fig 4. qPCR gene amplification – a) DNA denatured at ~95 °C; b) primers attached to matching genes and DNA anneals at ~68 °C; c) DNA elongates to form new double-stranded DNA; d) after next heating and annealing cycle the number of DNA copies doubles.

The number of thermal cycles needed before the number of gene copies (GC) exceeds a critical threshold (Cq – quantification cycle – the fluorescence at which the signal from the dye linked to DNA is significantly greater than the background fluorescence). Figure 5a illustrates fluorescence curves for known concentrations of a target gene’s DNA. A correlation curve can then be generated by plotting Cq as a function of DNA concentration (GC mL-1) as shown in Figure 5b.


Fig 5. qPCR standard curve – a) fluorescence as function of amplification cycles; b) Cq and a function of the number of gene copies mL-1 (Log10 GC mL-1).

The regression equation for the Figure 5b plot is then used to compute target gene Log10 CG mL-1 in test specimens. For the study reported in our recently published paper the primers were designed to detect either total prokaryotes (TP) or total fungi (TF). Results are reported as gene copies (or amplicon units – AU) rather than as cells because the number of copies each microorganism has of each gene varies among organisms and genes. Thus, for a particular gene, one type of microbe can have more GC than another. Similarly, a given microbe can have more copies of some genes than others. That said, as our investigation demonstrated, there is excellent agreement between ATP and qPCR bioburdens.

Results Comparison

As I discussed above, each microbiology property is affected by different factors. Most commonly, genetics and physiology affect concentrations of biomolecules in microorganisms. Rather than focus on linear correlation, it is more useful to compare attribute score agreement among parameters. For example, consider the relationship between height and weight (Figure 6). Although there is a good, positive correlation between the two parameters, there is substantial spread around the trend line. If one creates height and weight categories (short, medium, and tall; light, medium, and heavy) and compares the respective categorical scores, the height and weight scores agree for 44 % of the 88 individuals tested (Figure 6, green shaded regions; data points close to the trend line). For another 44 %, heights are greater than one would predict from subjects’ weights (Figure 6, purple zones; data points are well below the trend line). Only 12 % of the subjects were heavier than expected based on their height (Figure 6, blue-grey zones).


Fig 6. Scatter plot – relationship between height and weight – A) categorical scores for height and weight agree; B) categorical scores for height are greater than those for weight; C) categorical scores for height are less than those for weight.

Similarly, the plots for [cATP] (pg mL-1) versus qPCR (GC mL-1) had considerable scatter but, as shown in Figure 7, their respective categorical scores agreed for 60 % of the samples tested. The ATP-bioburden categorical scores were greater than the qPCR scores for 28 % of the samples and less than the qPCR scores for 12 %. In previous studies, agreement between ATP scores and those obtained by either culture testing or immunoassays were approximately 80 %. This probably reflects the greater variability of GC cell-1 and its impact on qPCR bioburden data.

This study used qPCR primers designed to detect all prokaryotes and all fungi, respectively. However, the growing library of primers now makes it possible to detect microbes with genes directly associated with specific types of biodeterioration (for example, microbiologically influenced corrosion). The test equipment and reagents make it possible to run qPCR in the field, on samples with [cATP] greater than a predetermined upper control limit. Additionally, DNA extracted for qPCR testing can also be used to obtain complete genetic profiles of contaminant populations.


Fig 7. ATP and qPCR categorical score (CS) agreement among 88 samples – A)CSATP = CSqPCR; B) CSATP > CSqPCR; C) CSATP < CSqPCR.

Next Steps

The study reported in June’s Access Microbiology paper was just a beginning. The testing was performed on samples available from a microcosm study. The timing was serendipitous. The good agreement between ATP and qPCR biomass determinations validated the qPCR test method. The next step will be to build a large database of fuel and fuel-associated water test results that include ATP, qPCR, and metagenomic profiles. ATP will provide total metabolically bioburden information. The qPCR data will provide quantitative measurements of various microorganisms of interest. The “of interest” list is likely to change as we get a better understanding of the types of microorganisms present and the relationship between those microbes and biodeterioration.

Summary

I am a proponent of tiered testing. Tier 1 tests are easy to perform while on-site near the point where I collect my samples. They provide reliable data within a few minutes. My primary, Tier 1 microbiology test is ATP (ASTM D4012 for interference-free, water samples, D7687 for fuel and fuel-associated water samples, and E2694 for metalworking fluid and lubricant samples). Although a differential test is available for distinguishing between bacterial and fungal contamination it does not provide gene-targeted test results the way qPCR does. Increasingly, qPCR is my go to Tier 2 test. When the [cATP] is greater than the upper control limit, I have a qualified lab run one or more qPCR tests. I am aware of several oilfield service companies whose field technicians run qPCR tests from the back of their cars. I am also using full genomic profiling to better understand whether specific types of microbes are always present when biodeterioration is occurring. By combining microbiological data with engineering, physical, and chemical data, I hope to be able to recommend more cost effective microbiological contamination control strategies.

I look forward to your thoughts and questions about how industry stakeholders can reverse this shrinking availability of biocidal products. Contact me at fr***@**********************ol.com.

THE CONTINUED IMPORTANCE OF MICROBICIDES IN INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS



The Challenge

At this year’s STLE Annual Meeting I presented a paper titled: “The continued importance of antimicrobial pesticides for controlling microbial contamination in industrial process fluids and systems.” Subsequently, the editors of Lube Magazine (https://www.lube-media.com/) invited me to write an article on the topic. That article – available from the Lube Media website only to Lube Magazine subscribers – was published in Lube Magazine, Issue 181, June 2024. I’ve also archived the article here on BCA’s website.

The crux of the issue is that for the past several decades, regulatory agencies have been increasingly myopic regarding the assessment of risks associated of biocidal products. The net effect has been a shrinking number of microbicidal active substances approved for use in Canada, Europe, the U.S., and other countries where microbicide use is regulated. The number of toxicological and environmental tests required to support new-product and registration renewal applications continues to grow as do end-use restrictions. For example, in 2000, the average cost for toxicological testing in support of industrial microbicide applications was less than $200,000 U.S. As of 2022, that average cost was between $1 million and $2 million U.S. The total global market for microbicides used in metalworking fluids (MWF) is estimated at $300 million U.S. Consequently, the potential return on investment no longer justifies the development of new active substances for controlling microbial contamination in MWF. Even the initial investment in toxicity testing to support product registrations is insufficient. All registered biocidal products are reviewed periodically for reregistration eligibility. In their 27 June 2008 Reregistration Eligibility Document (RED) for Hexahydro-1,3,5tris(2hydroxyethyl)-s-triazine (triazine), the U.S. EPA limited the maximum end-use dosage to 500 ppm – a dosage that’s less than the minimum concentration needed for triazine to work effectively. U.S. EPA’s OPP cited their concerns over formaldehyde exposure risk and their (incorrect) understanding of a 2023 paper.

Regulatory Agencies and Regulations

Table 1 lists selected regulatory agencies responsible for pesticide use oversight in the EU and specific countries, and the regulations under which the different agencies function. Within the EU, biocidal products approved by ECHAs Biocidal Products Committee (BPC) must also be approved the cognizant agencies of each country in which the products are sold. As for all products regulated under REACH, biocidal products are assessed based on their hazard (toxicological properties) rather than the risks associated with their use. Putatively, in the U.S., the U.S. EPA’s Office of Pesticide Programs (OPP) focuses on risk (the likelihood that users will suffer injuries). However, recent RED’s illustrate how OPP administrators tend to allow their understanding of hazard to trump the risk assessment (more on this below).

Table 1. National and Regional Agencies and Regulations Administering Microbicide Use.

Country/Region
Regulation
Agency
Canada Pest Control Products Act (PCPA) Pest Management Regulatory Agency (PMRA)
E.U. Biocidal Products Regulation (BPR) Biocidal Products Committee (BPC)
India Guidelines for the Registration of Biocide and Biocide Products Central Insecticide Board and Registration Committee (CIB&RC)
Japan Chemical Substances Control Law (CSCL) Ministry of Economy, Trade, and Industry (METI)
People’s Republic of China New Pesticide Management Regulation Institute for the Control of Agrochemicals, Ministry of Agriculture (ICAMA)
U.S. Federal Insecticide, Rodenticide, and Fungicide Act U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Pesticides Programs (U.S. EPA, OPP)

Note: a) This list illustrates the fact that globally there are numerous agencies responsible for regulating biocide use. It is not meant to be exhaustive.

The list of animal and ecotoxicological tests required varies by agency. In the U.S. an initial, relatively short list of toxicological tests are required in support of a pesticide application. The OPP representative reviewing the application can request additional tests. It is common for applicants to spend years incrementally supplying OPP with additional test results. Rather than either rejecting an application or providing the applicant with a compete list of additional tests that must be performed, OPP application reviewers tend to request additional tests, one at a time. For one product of which I am aware, the application for OPP approval for a product to be used in MWF has been going on for more than 15 years. In other instances, microbicide manufacturers had opted to withdraw heir products from the market rather than spend $ millions on additional toxicity, environmental fate and persistence, or both types of tests required in support of REDs. As a result, the number of microbicides available for use in MWF in the U.S. is <30 % of the number that were available in 1995. Similarly, in the EU, only 27 active substances are currently approved for use in MWF. That list was >200 in 1995.

Factors Driving Increased Regulatory Pressure

Hazard and risk conceptual conflation

You have no doubt seen variations of the meme in which a character is so focused on a relatively minor hazard that they are oblivious to a major one (Figure 1). A person backs away from a mouse and over a cliff, person is so focused on a bear cub that they remain unaware of the mama bear that’s about to attack – the examples go on. The issue is the same for the human tendency to conflate hazards with risks.


Fig 1. From the frying pan into the fire – person climbing the fence to escape the growling (petite) dog will undoubtedly not like the crocodiles waiting for him once he climbs over.

As I noted above, risk (R) is the likelihood (probability) that harm will occur. It is a function of hazard (H) and exposure (E), where hazard is the severity of harm likely to occur when the agent is contact, and exposure the degree of contact:

R = H x E      (1)

For chemical substances, hazard is assessed based on the doses at which different types of toxicological damage occur. Dosage for direct contact or ingestion is reported in mg of test substance per kg of test organism body weight (mg kg-1). For inhalation studies, it is reported as mg L-1 in the air the test organisms breath. Most commonly, the hazard measured is death, and the end point is the test substance concentration that kills half of the exposed population (lethal dose 50 – LD50 or lethal concentration – LC50). The acute tests that are required universally include:

  • Oral toxicity
  • Eye irritation
  • Dermal toxicity
  • Skin irritation
  • Inhalation toxicity
  • Skin sensitization

Other endpoints include tissue damage, impact on the test organisms’ metabolism, and other pathological symptoms. Acute toxicity tests measure the effect of a single exposure. Sub-chronic toxicity tests measure the effect of repeated exposures during a one-month test period. Chronic toxicity tests evaluate the test substance’s impact during the life of the test organism.

A chemical substance’s toxicity depends on its route of exposure. Figure 2a compares the acute oral toxicities of two chemicals I’ve designated as A and B. Figure 2b compares the acute dermal toxicities for the same two chemicals. Note that for oral toxicity, chemical A is more toxic than chemical B, but that for inhalation toxicity, B is more toxic than A. For chemical A, the oral LD50 = 200 mg kg-1 and the dermal LD50 is 1,000 mg L-1. Conversely, chemical B’s is more toxic through dermal contact than it is via the oral route.


Fig 2. Acute toxicity dose response curves – a) oral toxicity: substance A’s and B’s LD50 = 200 mg kg-1 and 750 mg kg-1, respectively; b) dermal toxicity: substance A’s and B’s LC50 = 1000 mg kg-1 and 100 mg kg-1, respectively.

In Figures 1a and 1b, none of the trend lines intersect with the Dose axis at 0 mg kg-1 or 0 mg L-1. The doses at which the trend lines intersect the Dose axis is called the no observable effect level (NOEL). Biological modeling plots toxicity test results to show the NOEL. Linear modelling forces the trend line through the origin (i.e., 0 % mortality at 0 mg kg-1 test substance concentration). If the four trendlines in Figure 1 were adjusted to go through the origin both test substances would appear to be more toxic than they actually are. The U.S. EPA uses the linear model to assess test substance toxicity. In other words, they tend to overestimate the hazard.

The second factor affecting risk is exposure. Exposure is a function of a substance’s concentration and the period of exposure. Being struck by a moving car is a hazard. The risk of being struck depends on the number of cars passing the exposed individual per unit of time (e.g., minute). In terms of cars passing per minute, in Figure 3 the couple walking on a country lane are exposed to a fraction of the cars to which the crowd walking on the freeway are. In industrial settings, without appropriate industrial hygiene controls in place (personal protective equipment, ventilation, etc.) workers handling concentrated chemicals potentially experience greater exposure than do workers exposed to diluted chemicals. However, when the workplace complies with hazardous material handling regulations, worker exposure is minimized.


Fig 3. Exposure – the couple on the left, walking on a country lane, are exposed to far fewer cars than are the people walking into a traffic-dense highway.

According to the Governors Highway Safety Association (GHSA), there were 7,485 pedestrians killed by moving vehicles in 2021. I’ll leave it for my readers to speculate how that statistic compares with the total number of industrial workers who have been killed by microbicide exposure in the past 100 years. When injuries have occurred, the cause has invariably failure to follow manufacturer’s handling instructions. The number of injuries associated with accidental exposure to non-biocidal chemicals is much greater than the number related to biocide exposure.

Narrow risk focus

Microbicides serve an important function. They are designed to control microbial contamination – they kill microorganisms. Globally, damage caused by microorganisms is estimated to cost hundreds of $ billions annually. These costs include spoilage (food, process fluids, specialty chemicals, paints and coatings, personal care products and countless other biodegradable materials), structural damage (primarily microbiologically influenced corrosion and biofouling), and health effects (allergies, toxemias, and infectious diseases). Microbicides play an essential role in reducing the health risks and other costs associated with microorganisms. However, regulatory agencies rarely consider the risks associated with not controlling microbiological contamination.

The formaldehyde issue

Currently, the U.S. EPA has targeted all formaldehyde-condensate microbicides for elimination. Their logic is:

Argument 1: Formaldehyde is a carcinogen.

Argument 2: Formaldehyde-condensate microbicides are manufactured by reacting formaldehyde with one or more other chemicals.

Argument 3: The mode of action of most formaldehyde-condensate microbicides is to release formaldehyde so that it can react with microorganisms’ structural and enzyme proteins.

Argument 4: If formaldehyde is released when formaldehyde-condensate microbicides kill microorganisms, it must also be released when those microbicides are diluted into treated fluids (e.g., metalworking fluids, paints, personal care products, etc.).

Therefore, people using formaldehyde-condensate microbicides are exposed to formaldehyde.

Unfortunately, this logic is flawed. The facts do not support argument 4. Modern analytical chemistry testing on fluids treated with formaldehyde-condensate microbicides have demonstrated that if any free-formaldehyde is present, it is at concentrations below detection levels (i.e., <1 μg kg-1 – ppb). Moreover, studies to test for formaldehyde in the air above formaldehyde-condensate microbicide treated and untreated metalworking fluids have determined that statistically there is no difference.

There’s a second flaw in the logic. The EPA recognizes that living beings produce formaldehyde. Except for the studies showing that formaldehyde concentrations in the air above untreated metalworking fluids were in the same range as above treated fluids, no research has reported the impact of uncontrolled microbial contamination on formaldehyde. Studies have also demonstrated that only formaldehyde-condensate microbicides denature endotoxins produced by Gram-negative bacteria that commonly grow in metalworking fluids. These last two considerations suggest that if formaldehyde-condensate microbicides can no longer be used in metalworking fluids, worker health risks due to endotoxin and other biological components (bioaerosols) would be greater than it is at present. It would be like rolling the microbial contamination control clock back to the 1960s when operators never had microbiological problems. Back then they only had odor problems.

In 1996, Lubrication Engineering published my paper: “Formaldehyde Risk in Perspective: A Toxicological Comparison of Twelve Biocides.” In that paper, I compared toxicity date for formaldehyde and a dozen MWF microbicides. The list included formaldehyde-condensates and nominally formaldehyde-free microbicides. In most test categories, the microbicidal products were less toxic than formaldehyde. None were either mutagenic or carcinogenic. Toxicity was not related to the presence of formaldehyde as a reactive intermediate.

The U.S. EPA has not been deterred by these facts. It is likely that formaldehyde-condensates will no longer be approved for use in MWF or other industrial applications.

Hysteria versus science

Equation 1 illustrated the relationship between hazard, risk, and exposure. It does not include the term that often overwhelms scientific assessment. That term is outrage. Outrage is the reaction individuals have to what they perceive to be unacceptable risk. This acceptability assessment is purely subjective. Risks that some people find totally acceptable, others find intolerable. Intolerance leads to outrage. Despite the well documented risks linked to smoking, the population of smokers consider the risk to be acceptable. Some non-smokers respond to secondary smoke exposure with outrage. Similarly, despite the nuclear power industry’s remarkable safety record, opponents of nuclear energy commonly react to proposed nuclear power generation facility construction proposals with outrage. Invariably, hard data are discarded when outrage appears. For biocides, it is the word itself rather than biocidal product toxicity that triggers outrage.

The words “biocide” or “microbicide” stimulate fear and anxiety even when the product’s toxicological data are more benign than those of other industrial chemicals. For example, in recent years a growing number of MWF compounders have been promoting biocide-free products. Some have been replacing traditional microbicides with an amine – dicyclohexylamine (DCHA). To date, the only published DCHA performance data demonstrate that it prevents uncontrolled microbial contamination from developing in MWF. Nothing has been reported about DCHA’s performance as a corrosion inhibitor, pH buffer, or other non-biocidal, functional additive. Figure 4 compares the acute oral, dermal, and inhalation toxicities of DCHA and hexahydro-1,3,5-tris(2-hydroxyethyl)-s-triazine (triazine – HHT). DCHA’s acute oral toxicity is 7x greater than HHT’s and its dermal toxicity is >10x that of HHT. Although HHT has a record of >70 years of safe, effective use, it is being replaced by a more toxic product that does not have a pesticide registration.


Fig 4. Toxicity comparison – dicyclohexylamine (DCHA) and hexahydro-1,3,5-tris(2-hydroxyethyl)-s-triazine (HHT).

A Rational Path Ahead

I have a simple proposition. Level the playing field. I suggest that governmental agencies responsible for industrial chemicals revise their regulations so that all industrial chemicals have the same data requirements for approval. Countless industrial chemicals are more toxic than those registered as biocidal products. Currently, the toxicological and environmental data available for many non-biocidal products are substantially more limited than data for biocidal products. Similarly, for a given chemical that has technical and biocidal uses, the amount of information required on a biocidal product’s label is substantially greater than on a technical product’s label (Figure 5).


Fig 5. Product labels for 10 % Sodium Hypochlorite (NaOCl – bleach) – a) label on household bleach bottle; b) master label for 10 % NaOCl as an algicide (22 pages).

Chemical substances’ adverse health effects are typically discovered only years after the general population has been exposed. If all products were required to be supported by the same toxicity and environmental data, manufacturers would lose their incentive to replace approved biocidal products with potentially more toxic substitutes.

Summary

Microbicides are under increasing regulatory pressure. This pressure translates into an increased number of tests requires in support of registration and reregistration applications. The additional tests are substantially more expensive than those run for technical grade chemicals and typically add up to more than $2 million U.S. These costs have a chilling impact against new microbicide development. The greater toxicity testing burden for biocidal products does not reflect either increased exposure risk or chemical hazard. It is based on hysterical reactions to the word biocide. The unintended consequences of this trend will be increased health risks and biodeterioration costs.

I look forward to your thoughts and questions about how industry stakeholders can reverse this shrinking availability of biocidal products. Contact me at fr***@**********************ol.com.

INDUSTRIAL MICROBIOLOGY – WHAT’S CHANGED?


Left Image – microbiologically influenced corrosion of petroleum pipeline; Right Image – industrial scale fermentation.

Introduction

In a recent book chapter (Noha M. Sorour, et al. 2017. Chapter 3 – Microbial Biosynthesis of Health-Promoting Food Ingredients, In: Alexandru Mihai Grumezescu, Alina Maria Holban, Eds, In Handbook of Food Bioengineering, Food Biosynthesis, pp: 25-54, Academic Press, New York, ISBN 9780128113721, https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/B9780128113721000038) industrial microbiology was defined as a branch of applied microbiology in which microorganisms are used for the production of important substances, such as antibiotics, food products, enzymes, amino acids, vaccines, and fine chemicals. With respect to the scope, objectives, and activities, industrial microbiology is synonymous with the term fermentation, as fermentation includes any process mediated by or involving microorganisms in which a product of economic value is obtained. There was no mention of microbial contamination control in this definition. I feel as though I missed The Memo.

When I first joined the organization then known as the Society of Industrial Microbiology (SIM; now, Society of Industrial Microbiology and Biotechnology – SIMB), annual meeting sessions largely focused on sessions about different ways that microbes could cause damage to industrial systems. In recent years, sessions on microbial contamination control have largely disappeared from annual meeting programs. What is going on?

Fermentation Art and Science

I don’t mean to suggest that historically, industrial microbiology did not include fermentation. In fact, archeological evidence suggests that the art of fermentation dates nearly as far back as ancient agriculture (i.e., before 10,000 BCE – Figure 1a). Leavened bread and fermented beverages have existed at least as long as written records. During the mid-19th century, Louis Pasteur and Robert Koch, respectively, proved conclusively that microorganisms were responsible for food spoilage and disease. In particular, Pasture championed the marriage of art and science in the world of fermentation (Figure 1b). Since the mid-20th century fermentation process science has expanded to include bioconversion of diverse feed stocks into innumerable products including, but not limited to, foods, flavors, pharmaceuticals, polymers, and solvents (Figure 1c). Fermentation science is now under the moniker biotechnology (the American Chemical Society defines biotechnology as “the application of biological organisms, systems, or processes by various industries to learning about the science of life and the improvement of the value of materials and organisms, such as pharmaceuticals, crops, and livestock.”).


Fig 1. History of fermentation – a) ancient grain collecting and fermentation; b) mid-19th century brewery; c) modern biotechnology facility.

We have come a long way from the earliest attempts to ferment foods as a means of preservation and alcoholic beverage production! Still, I feel that industrial microbiology’s current definition ignores an important aspect of the discipline’s scope – microbiological contamination control.

Microbiological Contamination Control

Biocides ascendant

It has been speculated that the earliest attempts to preserve foods was through fermentation and that kimchi (fermented cabbage) was developed in the 10th century BCE. The earliest recorded use of minerals as biocidal agents was the use of sulfur in ~2,500 BCE. Arsenic, lead, mercury, have been used as antimicrobial control agents since at least the 2nd century BCE. In 1867, Joseph Lister introduced the first organic antimicrobial agent – phenol (Figure 2a) – as an antimicrobial agent to prevent wound sepsis. Subsequently, phenol was used widely as a surface contact disinfectant.

The number of available organic microbicides grew dramatically between the 1930s and 1970s. Early oilfield microbiology research demonstrated that polychlorinated phenols (trichlorophenol and pentachlorophenol) did an excellent job of inhibiting sulfate reducing bacteria from causing problems when water was injected into petroleum formations. From the mid-1940s until their use was banned in the early 1970s, polychlorinated phenols (Figures 2b and 2c) were the predominant oilfield microbicides. Once chlorinated phenols were banned, glutaraldehyde (Figure 2d) and quaternary ammonium compounds (Quats – Figure 2e) became the most used oilfield microbicides. There are now hundreds of quats available for use in various applications. After the development of water-miscible metalworking fluids (MWF), the need for microbicides became apparent. Hexahydro-1,3,5-tris(2-hydroxyethyl)-s-triazine (Figure 2f) and several oxazolidine biocides dominated the application, although, by 1990, nearly 200 active substances for use n MWF were approved by the U.S. EPA. I’m not trying to provide a comprehensive review of organic biocide history here. My point is that, entering into the 1990s, there were many of microbicidal active substances available for use in industrial applications.


Fig 2. Selected organic microbicides – a) phenol; b) trichlorophenol; c) pentachlorophenol; d) glutaraldehyde; e) quaternary ammonium compound (R1 through R4 are organic – CH – radicals, the chemistry of which can vary by chain length, degree of substitution, presence of oxygen, and ring structures); f) Hexahydro-1,3,5-tris(2-hydroxyethyl)-s-triazine.

Biocides descendant

Since the mid-1990s, two factors have contributed to substantially reduce the number of active substances available to use in various industries – regulatory pressure and industry consolidation (Figure 3).


Fig 3. The incredible shrinking list of microbicidal active substances and the factors driving that shrinkage.

First the agencies responsible for biocide regulation have changed. In the U.S., the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency assumed responsibility in the early 1970s. In the EU, the European Chemical Agency’s Biocidal Products Committee was chartered under the 1998 Biocidal Products Directive (Directive 98/8/EC). As I’ve noted above, tri- and pentachlorophenol use was banned in the early 1970s after they were found to be carcinogenic and persistent in the environment. The types of toxicity and environmental fate data needed to support biocidal product registrations, are substantially greater than those needed to register non-biocidal, technical products. The cost of completing a full toxicological evaluation are estimated at $2 U.S. million to >$10 million U.S. For biocides used in niche applications, such as MWF or jet fuel, the addressable market does not justify the expense. Moreover, the timeline between initial registration application and regulatory agency approval can be greater than ten years. In the U.S., after recommending that formaldehyde be found to pose an unreasonable risk, the EPA has targeted formaldehyde-condensate microbicides for special scrutiny. This, despite the fact that the toxicological profiles of formaldehyde-condensate microbicides is substantially different (more benign) than that of formaldehyde and the free-formaldehyde cannot be detected in fluids treated with these active substances.

The second factor is industry consolidation. In 1990, there were numerous microbicide producers in the U.S. and EU. Since then, corporate acquisition has eliminated >90 % of the companies that once produced microbicides. In most cases, the industrial biocide business units represent a negligible fraction of the companies’ annual revenues. In corporations where projects valued at <$100 million U.S. are not supported, new biocidal product development never stands a chance (the total MWF biocide market is estimated at <$300 million U.S.).

Combined, these two factors translate to a greatly reduced list of active substances approved for use in various industrial applications and, in most market sectors, reduced career opportunities for microbiologists.

Old-school industrial microbiology did not focus solely on biocide selection and use. However, controlling microbiological contamination and reducing biodeterioration risk was a primary research objective. Thus the increased regulator pressure against biocide use has also adversely affected this branch of microbial ecology research.

Impact on Old-School Industrial Microbiologists

When I’m asked about my profession, I tell folks that I am an industrial microbial ecologist. I investigate the ecology of microorganisms that infect industrial systems and potentially cause damage to the systems, their contents, or both. There are industrial sectors in which microbial contamination control is still recognized as being a valuable pursuit. For example, there’s a considerable amount of excellent oilfield microbiology research and development. Two international conferences focus on the topic (ISMOS and RMF). Similarly, the Energy Institute has an active Petroleum Microbiology Committee, ASTM has a Fuel Microbiology Working Group, and the International Air Transport Association has a Jet Fuel Microbiology Panel. Conversely, at the STLE 2024 Annual Meeting, I presented the only paper addressing MWF microbiology. Historically, STLE Annual Meeting programs included five to ten papers, presented by representatives of biocide producers, MWF compounders, and MWF end users. Those companies who still have staff microbiologists are not allowing those people to participate in professional society activities. This lack of support in the MWF sector is particularly notable because the tools now available for understanding the microbial ecology of MWF systems promise to provide ways to develop more cost-effective microbial contamination control strategies. Moreover, the potential adverse health effects of uncontrolled microbial contamination have been well documented.

Since 1999, I’ve been teaching MWF microbiology as part of STLE’s education program. I’ve carried on a legacy started by Prof. Ed Bennett (University of Houston) – the individual I consider to be the father of MWF microbiology and the person responsible for initiating educational programs at STLE (then ASLE) annual meetings. Ed was succeeded by another MWF microbiologist (Frank Mallek) and Frank was succeeded by Prof Harold Rossmoore (Wayne State University). After 25 years as an STLE course developer, I’m stepping down. Although I have a successor in mind, I don’t know whether his employer will support his involvement with STLE education. I anticipate that there will be interesting times ahead and that a new generation of industrial microbial ecologists will need to relearn the lessons learned by previous generations.

As always, please share your comments and questions with me at fr***@**********************ol.com.

MICROBIOLOGY FOR THE UNITINTIATED – PART 7: FUNGI


Penicillium citrinum – a common fungal contaminant from water-miscible metalworking fluids. Source: penicillium-citrinum-890c723a-deef-4dea-b2db-de048c4df2a-resize-750.jpg (600×806) (alchetron.com)

Introduction

In my September 2023 post, I provided an overview of bacteria the biological domain that includes millions of taxa that share both genetic similarities and an absence of visible internal structures. After a three-month hiatus, I’ll now provide a similar overview of fungi. Fungi is a kingdom of eucaryotic organisms that are members the domain Eucarya. As illustrated in September’s What’s New post, figure 2, Eucarya includes all organisms that have a membrane-bound nucleus. The domain includes organisms ranging in size from single cell algae to 30 m (98 ft) long, 199 metric ton (219 US ton) blue whales (Figure 1). The kingdom Fungi is taxonomically diverse – including yeasts, molds, and mushrooms (Figure 2 – note: yeasts and molds are two different morphologies; not different taxonomic groups). The fungi associated with industrial process fluids are all within the phyla Ascomycota and Mucromycota (recall from September’s post, that phIyla are the tier below kingdoms).

Fungal Taxonomy

Genera within the phyla Ascomycota (Ascomycetes) and Mucormycota (Zygomycetes) have filamentous, vegetative hyphae and spore-bearing aerial hyphae (Figures 3 and 4). As illustrated in Figure 5, Ascomycota spores are contained in sacs but Mucormycota spores are not. Moreover, some fungal species are dimorphic – they have both filamentous and yeast morphologies (forms – Figure 6). Although historically, fungal taxonomy was based primarily on appearance (morphology) and physiology (eating habits), the discipline is now moving toward genetic classification.


Fig 1. Examples of organisms in the domain Eukarya – a) single-cell alga; b) Giardia sp.; c) fungus (mushroom); d) plant (fern); e) blue whale.



Fig 2. Fungi – a) yeast cells; b) mold cells (filamentous hyphae and aerial spore-bearing bodies}.



Fig 3. Ascomycota – a) Aspergillus fumigatus colony; b) spore-bearing conidiophores; c) close-up of conidiospores on a conidiophore; d) vegetative hyphae.



Fig 4. Mucromycota – a) Rhizopus sp. Colony; b) spore-bearing sporangiophores; c) close-up of a sporangiophore with sporangiospores; d) vegetative rhizoids.



Fig 5. Mold morphology – a) Ascomycota; b) Mucormycota.



Fig 6. Dimorphic fungus Candida albicans – a) yeast form; b) mold form.

Fungus reproduction

The life cycles of Ascomycetes and Mucoromycetes (Zygomycetes) are similar. As noted above both divisions reproduce sexually and asexually. Spores are formed during asexual reproduction and can persist for centuries until conditions are favorable for germination. Yeasts reproduce by budding (see July 2024, Figure 5). For filamentous forms, most fungal biomass is in the vegetative hyphae. Masses of fungal filaments have been discovered that weigh several metric tons and occupy 1,000s of m3. In liquids such as fuels, lubricants and metalworking fluids, molds typically form spherical colonies. When the aerial hyphae (spore-bearing bodies) develop on the inside of the colony, the spheres are smooth and slimy (Figure 7a – I call these fisheyes). When the areal hyphae develop facing the outside, the spheres are fuzzy (Figure 7b – I call spheres in this form scuzzballs). Fungal growth at the fuel-water interface can form thick, impenetrable masses (Figure 8a). Similar masses can form on MWF system surfaces (Figures 8b and 8c).


Fig 7. Spherical fungal colonies in liquid – a) fisheyes (aerial hyphae are inside of the sphere); b) scuzzballs (areal hyphae are outside the sphere).



Fig 8. Fungal masses in fluid systems – a) fungal mat at fuel-water interface; b) mold colonies on surface of water-miscible metalworking fluid (MWF) in 50 L sump; c) membranous fungal mass pulled off of MWF sluice.

Physiology

In previous posts, I’ve commented that all organisms need water to grow and proliferate. As a kingdom, fungi need less water than bacteria. Water activity (aw is a measure of water’s availability in a solvent). Bacteria typically become dormant when aw ≤0.9. Most fungi can thrive at aw ≥ 0.7. Bacterial grow optimally in the pH 6 to 8 range but fungi prefer pH 5 to 6.

The fungi that infect industrial process fluid systems such as fuel and metalworking fluids can typically proliferate on simple sugars such as glucose. However, many taxa are nutritionally adaptable and can use a variety of organic molecules – including hydrocarbons – as their sole carbon source. Hormoconus resinae, one of the fungal species commonly recovered from fuels, has been shown to degrade ultra-low sulfur diesel (ULSD) by > 60 % (w/w) in < 30 days under laboratory conditions. Degradation includes mineralization to carbon dioxide, partial fuel molecule breakdown (for example aromatics to aliphatics), conversion to new biomass, and metabolism to waste products. There are thousands of volatile, fungal metabolites (MVOC – microbial volatile organic compounds). Many are allergenic – commonly causing sick building syndrome in homes and commercial buildings. Some (e.g., aflatoxin produced by some Aspergillus species) are carcinogenic. Mycotoxins (including hallucinogens) are toxic metabolites produced by fungi. MVOC are primarily associated with fungal spores. Despite the variety of MVOCs, the predominant odors associated with fungal contamination are yeasty or musty (think of a locker room, old damp house, or pile of rotting potatoes). Few studies have investigated MVOC concentrations in industrial facilities. Health and safety studies that have performed at facilities using water-miscible metalworking fluids (MWF) suggest that health risks associated with MVOC exposure do not add significantly to those posed by overall exposure to MWF mist.

Summary

Historically thought to be just one evolutionary step after the bacteria, the domain Fungi is now recognized to be genetically close to plants and animals on the tree of life. Taxonomically and morphologically diverse as a kingdom, the morphological forms that infect industrial systems are yeasts and molds. Because of the masses of filamentous, vegetative hyphae they form, fungi are commonly responsible for plugging lines, filters, and parts washer screens. Fungal MVOC can be noxious, allergenic, toxic, and carcinogenic. Most commonly, fungi are found in multi-organism consortia that include bacteria.

As always, please share your comments and questions with me at fr***@**********************ol.com.

MICROBIOLOGY FOR THE UNITINTIATED – PART 6: BACTERIA


A rod-shaped, polarly flagellated bacterium.
Source: https://factrepublic.com/facts/33765/

Introduction

Now that I’ve provided an overview of the characteristics of all life, I’ll describe the most common types of organisms that contaminate industrial process fluid systems – i.e., oilfield injected and produced waters, fuel-associated waters, heat exchange systems, and countless other systems in which fluids are contained of through which they flow. Historically, the two primary types of microbes recovered from systems not exposed to light are bacteria and fungi. More recently a third group – archaea – have been detected too. When light is present, algae are common contaminants. In this article I’ll discuss bacteria. In future articles I’ll focus on each of the other types of microbes.

The Tree of Life

Taxonomy is the science of classifying living things. In 1735, Carl Linnaeus published Systema Naturae in which he described a binomial system for identifying plants (i.e., originally plant and subsequently all organism based on whether they shared or didn’t share a characteristic). Under Linnaean taxonomy, there are eight categorical levels (Figure 1). The highest – most inclusive – level is domain. As illustrated in Figure 3a, there are three domains – Bacteria, Archaea, and Eucarya. Each domain is divided into Phyla. Thus far, the domain Bacteria has approximately 1,300 phyla – with the number still increasing. Phyla are further divided among classes. Again, using Bacteria as our example, the phylum Proteobacteria is comprised of five Classes – Alphaproteobacteria (α-proteobacteria), Betaproteobacteria (β-proteobacteria), Gammaproteobacteria (γ-proteobacteria), Deltaproteobacteria (δ-proteobacteria) and Epsilonproteobacteria ( ε-proteobacteria). The γ-proteobacteria includes 14 Orders which are further divided into 404 Families. For example, the Order Pseudomonadales includes two Families – Moraxellaceae and Pseudomonadaceae – both of which include bacteria commonly recovered from industrial process water systems. Families are comprised of genera (singular – genus). Thus, the genus Pseudomonas is a member of the family Pseudomonadaceae. Traditionally, species was the smallest taxonomic unit (for example Pseudomonas aeruginosa). However, current taxonomic schemes typically include two additional levels – strains and biovariants (abbreviated as biovar.).


Fig 1. Linnaean taxonomy’s eight taxonomic levels.


Fig 2. Phylogenic trees – a) simplified tree showing genetic distances between Bacteria, Archaea, and Fungi; b) more complex genomic map illustrating Bacteria’s emergence approximately 3.2 billion years ago, Archaea’s emergence approximately 1.5 billion years ago, and fungi arriving at approximately the same time as vascular plants – approximately 1 billion years ago. Sources: a) Carreón, Gustavo & Hernández-Zavaleta, Jesús Enrique & Miramontes, Pedro. (2005). DNA Circular Game of Chaos. 757. 10.1063/1.1900503, b) https://i.pinimg.com/originals/46/28/92/46289232f53138d4134ea0e829589d09.gif, c) https://organismalbio.biosci.gatech.edu/biodiversity/eukaryotes-and-their-origins/.

In traditional taxonomy – including microbial taxonomy – organisms were clustered based on their observable similarities. Thus, members of a genus share more characteristics than members of a family. Diversity increases with the classification level. Currently, microbial taxonomists estimate there are at least a billion bacterial species, of which fewer than 10,000 have been characterized (that’s <0.001 % in case you are wondering). Figure 1b offers a visual perspective on the diversity of bacterial life. The black, web-like region on the bottom left reflects the genetic branching since bacteria first existed – an estimated 3.2 billion years ago (the Earth’s estimated age is 4 billion years). I don’t expect readers to use Figure 2b as anything more than an illustration of just how divers the kingdom Bacteria is. Figure 1c provides a simplified tree showing first the evolution of eukaryotes as hosts for bacteria and second the similar age of the Archaea and Eukaryote domains. Figure 3c also illustrates how genetic material (ribonucleic acid – RNA, deoxyribonucleic acid – RNA, and proteins were probably components of self-replicating proto-microbes before the last universal common ancestor (LUCA). Based on genomic analyses, the LUCA is estimated to have existed between 3.48 and 4.1 billion years ago – soon after Earth formed. Although the term LUCA suggests that there was a single genetic entity from which all subsequent life evolved, it is more likely that numerous types of protomicrobes developed and the most successful continued to evolve.

What are Bacteria?

ASTM provides a good working definition. A bacterium is any member “of a class of microscopic single-celled organisms reproducing by fission or by spores. Characterized by round, rod-like, spiral, or filamentous bodies, often aggregated into colonies or mobile by means of flagella. Widely dispersed in soil, water, organic matter, and the bodies of plants and animals. Either autotrophic (self-sustaining, self-generative), saprophytic (derives nutrition from nonliving organic material already present in the environment), or parasitic (deriving nutrition from another living organism).” I discussed bacterial reproduction in July 2023.

By current estimates, Bacteria are the most diverse organisms. To paraphrase Donald Rumsfeld’s “Known knowns” comment, bacterial diversity and total biomass estimates fall into the category of known unknowns. Figure 3 illustrates a typical dendogram created from DNA data from a soil sample. The dendrogram’s branches represent genetic similarities, with similarities between two DNA molecules increasing as the dendogram branches from left to right. Most commonly, the individual organism type – operational taxonomic units (OTU) are identified only by alphanumeric codes. This is because only a small percentage of bacterial OTU that have been detected by genomic profiling have been identified at the Family, Genus, or Species levels. During the past decade, some researchers have suggested that apparent similarities among DNA molecules based on their migration through an electric field gel (denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis – DGGE – see the black bands in the center of Figure 3) is misleading. DNA molecules with different genes can appear to be common OTUs. Some have argued the amplicon sequence variant (ASV) is more precise. Repeating my mantra, I make this point only to illustrate my point about bacterial diversity. As I explained in my July 1018 What’s New article, unlike antibiotics which are designed to kill specific microbes without damaging surrounding human cells (or microbes that are essential for good health), industrial microbicides typically target a broad spectrum of microbes. My favorite analogy is Bambi v. Godzilla (Figure 4). Full taxonomic profiles can be useful to understand the microbial ecology of the system under investigation, but is unlikely to inform contamination control decisions.


Fig 3. Dendogram of genomic profile of bacteria recovered form water samples. Source: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0261970


Fig 4. Bambi versus Godzilla (Source: 1969 animated feature – https://www.indiewire.com/2015/01/a-bambi-meets-godzilla-live-action-remake-123687/#!)

Classifying Bacteria

Shape

Recognizing that the microscope was the first tool use to detect and identify bacteria, the earliest taxonomic schemes were based on their appearance (morphology). With variations within each group, the primary forms are rod, spheres, commas, and spirals (Figure 5). Once the Gram stain – developed by Hans Christian Gram – was able to differentiate between bacteria with cell walls thet retained an iodine-based stain and those that didn’t – bacteria in each of the morphological groups were classified as being either Gram positive (Figure 6a) or Gram negative (Figure 6b).


Fig 5. Primary bacterial morphologies.


Fig 6. Primary bacterial morphologies after Gram staining – a) Gram positive rods; b) Gram negative rods; c) Gram positive spheres; d) gram negative spheres; e) Gram negative commas; f) Gram positive spirals; and g) Gram negative spirals.

It would be decades before the biochemical basis for Gram positive and Gram negative reactions were understood. As illustrated in Figure 7, the Gram positive cell walls are structurally less complex from those of Gram negative bacteria. The largely carbohydrate Gram positive cell wall retains the iodine stain. The peptidoglycan structure of Gram negative cells do not. Other groups of microbes have subsequently been classified based on their reactions to specific stains (acid fast stain, spore stain, etc.).


Fig 7. Cell wall structure – a) Gram positive cell (mostly peptidoglycan); b) Gram negative cell (the cell wall is substantially more complex; the peptidoglycan layer is covered by a lipopolysaccharide layer).

Although morphology can be a useful tool, it is limited due to bacterial pleomorphism – the ability of a specific microbe’s shape to change in response to its environment. More that 20 years ago, researchers at University of Montana’s Center for Biofilm Engineering demonstrated that during biofilm development both the morphology and physiology of genetically identical cells varied, depending on where cells were located within the biofilm matrix. I’m not sure why this was such a startling discovery. Just consider the morphological and physiological diversity of human cells, depending on where they are in (or on our bodies – Figure 8).


Fig 8. Human tissue cells – a) epidermis (skin); b) hair follicle cells; c) lung cells; d) nerve cell; e) retinal cells; f) stomach cells; g) tongue cells.

Physiology

Before genetic testing became affordable and readily accessible, physiological tests were the primary tool – after morphology – to identify microbes. Physiological testing profiles a microbe’s ability to utilize specific nutrients (e.g., glucose or other sugars, various amino acids, hydrocarbons, etc.), produce characteristic metabolites (e.g., ethanol, acetic acid, various gases, etc.), or grow under particular conditions (e.g., oxic or anoxic; acidic, neutral, or alkaline; cold, temperate or hot; etc.). A full battery of physiological tests can include more than 400 different conditions. Traditional microbiological taxonomy standards (for example, Bergey’s Manual of Determinative Bacteriology – nine editions published between 1923 and 1994 – was long considered to be the bible for bacterial identification).

One underappreciated limitation of physiological testing is that these tests could only be run on microbes that could be cultivated in the first place. Moreover, the physiological capabilities of a pure culture can vary with the culture’s age. Consequently, cultures are subject to misidentification due to the variations in their physiological properties as a function of age. I one project, I sent specimens from a single colony to several different labs. Although all the labs used the same automated physiological testing equipment, each lab reported different identities for the culture. When specimens of the same culture were sent to several labs for genetic testing, all identified the microbe correctly.

That said, grouping microbes into physiological classes to assess biodeterioration risk can be useful. I routinely run BART™ (BART – Biological Activity Reaction Test – is a trademark of Droycon Bioconcepts, Inc., Regina, Canada) tests on fuel or fuel-associated water samples that have high ATP-bioburdens. BART vials each contain one of nine different dried media. I typically test for acid producing bacteria (APB), iron related bacteria (IRB), denitrifying bacteria (DN), nitrifying bacteria (NB), slime-forming bacteria (SLYM), and sulfate reducing bacteria (SRB) – microbes commonly associated with microbiologically influenced corrosion. Figure 9 illustrates the reactions in APB, IRB, SLYM, and SRB BART vials inoculated from fuel-associated water.


Fig 9. BART (left to right) APB, IRB, SLYM, and SRB vials inoculated with fuel-associated water – a) Immediately after inoculation; b) after 4-days incubation. The sample was positive for all four metabolic groups.

Figure 9a shows the vials’ appearances immediately after inoculation. Figure 9b shows how each vial changed color and became turbid after four-days’ incubation. The microbes growing in each vial represented diverse types of individual taxa that shared a physiological property – i.e., acid production, etc.

Similarly, representatives from diverse taxa are included in each respiration and fermentation category (see August 2023). Classifying microbes based on their ecologically important physiological properties is like classifying trades people based on their skills – carpenters, electricians, plumbers, welders, etc. It provides no indication of their family lineages.

Optimal and Tolerated Growth Conditions

Just as genetically diverse microbes fall into different physiological categories, they also fall into different growth condition categories. Here, I’m using growth condition to include environmental factors such as temperature, pH, and salinity.

Temperature

Psychrophilic bacteria grow optimally at temperatures between 10 °C and 15 °C. Most will not grow at temperatures >20 °C. Mesophiles – the microbes most commonly associated with disease – require moderate temperatures in the 20 °C to 40 °C range. Most bacteria isolated from fuel and industrial process fluid systems where temperatures are typically <45 °C are mesophilic. Thermophiles require hotter temperatures (≥45 °C). Thermophiles have been recovered from environments where the temperature is >100 °C. Figure 10 illustrates how microbes are classified based on the temperature range in which they will grow.


Fig 10. Microbe classification by optimal and tolerated temperatures.

pH

The Mirriam-Webster online dictionary defines pH as “a measure of acidity and alkalinity of a solution that is a number on a scale on which a value of 7 represents neutrality and lower numbers indicate increasing acidity and higher numbers increasing alkalinity and on which each unit of change represents a tenfold change in acidity or alkalinity and that is the negative logarithm of the effective hydrogen-ion concentration or hydrogen-ion activity in gram equivalents per liter of the solution.” Mathematically,

pH = -Log10 [H+]

Where “p” is a term with an interesting history (which I won’t share here). In water, the fractional sum of hydrogen (H+) and hydroxide (OH–) ions is always 1. As shown in Figure 11, pH decreases as Log10 [H+] increases. At neutral pH, Log10 [H+] = Log10 [OH–]. Neutrophiles only grow when the in the pH range 7 ± 1.5. Acidophiles thrive at lower pHs. Some (extreme acidophiles) grow in water with pH = 1. Conversely, alkalinophiles require pH ≥ 9 (Figure 12).


Fig 11. Relationships between hydrogen ([H+] and hydroxyl ([OH–]) ions and pH.


Fig 12. Microbe classification by optimal and tolerated pH ranges.

Other environmental conditions

Microbes can also be classified based on their preference (i.e., condition for optimal or maximal growth) for atmospheric pressure (barophiles only grow in environments with pressures ≥ 10,000 kPa (100x atmospheric pressure, and vacuumphiles grow in environments with pressures in the 5 kPa to 15 kPa range – 0.05x to 0.14x atmospheric pressure), osmotic pressure, salinity, radiation, or other factors that span ranges that select for different microbes at different requins of the parameter’s range. Organisms that prefer life at the high or low ends of each factor are called extremophiles. Some types of microbes enjoy environments that are extreme by more than one criterion. For example, microbes thriving around deep-sea ocean vents are thermophilic barophiles. They require both high temperatures and pressures.

Most higher life forms can tolerate only a narrow (in Goldilocks terms – just right) range of each of these factors. Bacteria and archaea are unique in the range of environmental conditions they enjoy as kingdoms. However, individual taxa are limited in the range of environments in which they can thrive. Still each time a group of scientists report they have discovered an environment on Earth that is completely devoid of life, they are proven wrong. The development of genetic testing has made it possible to detect bacteria and archaea (more on archaea in my next article) that had previously been undetectable. Regarding the ability of one or more life forms to exist in Earth’s most hostile environments, Carl Sagan’s adage – “The absence of evidence is not evidence of absence” – has been proven true. Of course, Professor Sagan was referring to life beyond earth. We will have to wait and see on that front.

Summary

The domain Bacteria is genetically the most ancient and diverse of the three domains into which all life on earth is divided. To date, microbiologists estimate that we have detected <0.001 % of the different types of bacteria thought to exist in nature. Although the tools used to traditionally identify bacteria are still of some value, genomic test methods have changed the game. Microbes that once seemed to be closely related, based on their appearance and nutritional characteristics (physiology) have been shown to be genetically distant. Conversely, other microbes, once thought to be dissimilar are now known to be close genetic relatives. Because of their ecological and physiological diversity, bacteria play major roles in biotransformation processes (I’ll write about nutrient cycles in future What’s New articles). When biotransformation causes damage, we call it biodeterioration. When it is used to produce useful products, we call it biotechnology, and when it facilitates remediation, we call it bioremediation. We need to remember that microbes live their lives unaware of the labels we humans apply to their activities.

In this article I have barely scratched bacteriology’s surface. Quite often clients ask me to provide them with a list of microbes present in a contaminated system. I invariably ask what they will do with that information. In my opinion, the art and science of microbial contamination control depends on understanding what the population is doing rather than identifying taxonomic names. What do you think? As always, please share your comments and questions with me at fr***@**********************ol.com.

OUR SERVICES

  • Consulting Services
  • Condition Monitoring
  • Microbial Audits
  • Training and Education
  • Biocide Market Opportunity Analysis
  • Antimicrobial Pesticide Selection

REQUEST INFORMATION





    Skip to content